Friday, September 18, 2020

RIP Larry Wilson

 By John Turney

Credit: Merv Corning 

Earlier today, the Arizona Cardinals announced the passing of Larry Wilson, one of the true greats of the game. Wilson checked all the boxes—All-time teams, statistics, testimonials, innovations, intangibles, you name it.

He was a member of the NFL's 100th Anniversary Team (2019), NFL All-Time Team (2000), NFL 75th Anniversary Team (1994), NFL 50th Anniversary team (runner-up) (1969), NFL 1960s All-Decade Team, 1970 All-Decade (Second-team) and was a six-time All-Pro and went to eight Pro Bowls. He was named NFL Defensive Player of the Year in 1966 when he led the NFL with 10 interceptions. 

He ended his career had 52 interceptions, 21 sacks. eight defensive scores (7 defensive TDs and one safety). 

He didn't "invent" the safety blitz per se but he popularized and utilized more than anyone in the 1960s. He was known for toughness playing in games with broken bones in both his hands and had numerous broken noses.

In a statement released by the Cardinals Wilson is quoted as saying "In a football game, you've only got 60 minutes to prove what kind of player you are. Forty-nine minutes aren't enough. You've got to give 100% on every play."

Wilson did that. And more.

1948 Don Hutson NFL All-Time Team

 LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films

Today, PFJ will take a look at the NFL All-Time Team by the great Don Hutson. In 1948, just three years after retiring from the Packers as a player, Hutson gave the Green Bay Press-Gazette his All-Time Team of players he played against. He included five players from the rival Chicago Bears, and maybe one surprise be naming Giants end Jim Poole. 

Hutson choose:

Ends- Bill Hewitt, Jim Poole

Tackles- Turk Edwards, George Christensen

Guards- Dan Fortmann, Riley Matheson

Center- Bulldog Turner

Quarterback- Sid Luckman

Halfbacks- Cliff Battles, Steve Van Buren

Fullback- Bronko Nagurski

(Source: Green Bay Press-Gazette, Nov. 24, 1948)

Wednesday, September 16, 2020

1944 Johnny Blood NFL All-Time Team

 LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films
Johnny "Blood" McNally, Packers

Today PFJ looks at the NFL All-Time Team from Johnny "Blood" McNally. In 1944 McNally was asked to list his all-time team. He praised Don Hutson, so much that he listed 3 ends on his team. 

One of his biggest surprise was that he selected Father Lumpkin as his blocking back (or quarterback spot). McNally choose:

Ends- Don Hutson, Bill Hewitt, Brick Mueller

Tackles- Cal Hubbard, Pete "Fats" Henry

Guards- Mike Michalske, Dan Fortmann

Center- Mel Hein

Quarterback-Blocking Back- Father Lumpkin

Halfbacks- Dutch Clark (LHB), Sammy Baugh (RHB)

Fullback- Bronko Nagurski

(Source: Marshfield News-Herald, Aug. 4, 1944)


Tuesday, September 15, 2020

TUESDAY TIDBITS: "Drifted Over to the Right"

By TJ Troup

We have one week in the books of the 2020 NFL season and was very impressed with the quality of football played this past weekend. Always some surprises, and of course some of the games and teams were true to form. 

Before the season began Conor Orr at SI listed what he believed to be each teams record for the season. Not sure if Mr. Orr has ever placed a wager, and without a War & Peace saga of my betting history—wagering on Pro Football is not very easy. 

The week to week with point spreads is daunting enough, and as such much of my success was season win totals. Since Paul Lionel Zimmerman was not allowed to bet due to SI policy, he was very helpful for me as we would discuss what we thought my best bets would be.

 First off, you NEVER bet a total that is a whole number! Whether you bet over or under the total the listed total for the team in Vegas must have a 1/2 involved. Mr. Orr stated he did not want anyone to challenge his selections, and recently he shared that he was not near as confident in his win totals. 

Lack of confidence? No backbone? No conviction? Imagine Conor Orr in a room with me and Dr. Z? Possibly a puddle of tears under his desk after we would challenge him? 

All that said, here are a few of his totals, and for those of you keeping score, would relish your comments in late December. Orr has Pittsburgh winning 13 games. Wore my Jack Butler jersey last night, and thoroughly enjoyed the road victory, BUT the Steelers will not win 13 games, total will be less. Probably a playoff team, but not with 13 wins. 

Next up you ask? New Orleans with 14 wins—Orr is delusional. Saints sure looked impressive Sunday and are no doubt a playoff team, but New Orleans will win less than 14. The Seahawks earned a road victory, but their total is also far too high; strongest division in football, and as such they will win less than 12 games. 

Orr has the 49ers at 8-8, and though they lost San Francisco will win at least 9 games. Finally my beloved Bears—and Orr has them winning 6 games. Since they won on the road and do not play a first-place schedule this year, Chicago is my most confident bet—they will win at least 7, and only need to go 6-9 the rest of the way, and play NYG at home this Sunday. Five wagers, we will see how Orr does against me. 

Michael Rothstein at ESPN detailed the Lions collapse on Sunday, and will use the title "dead man walking" for this next segment. Detroit has had the lead in 20 of the 33 4th quarters in which Matt P. has been coach. Eleven times he lost the lead, and 10 of those became losses (tie with Cardinals last year is the other). His corners has injury issues, and the lack of discipline by Jamie Collins demonstrates Detroit is headed for last place. Matt P. is 0-1, and the following three weeks he faces Green Bay on the road, the Cardinals on the road, and the Saints at home on October 4th. 

Then the bye week; will Matt P. be the head coach of the Lions when Detroit heads to Jacksonville on October 18th? If there is a change, hopefully, the Lions will hire someone who actually can teach pass defense since Matt P. does not have a clue. Don't believe me, watch the replay of the loss on Sunday, and get back to me. 

Tom Sestak (70) chases Len Dawson

Each week in this column will detail a historical aspect or performance. September 13th, 1964 the Buffalo Bills opened the season with a convincing victory over the Kansas City Chiefs. Lou Saban and his main lieutenant Joel Collier have built the best defense in the AFL, and the Chiefs are about to get a lesson from the Lake Erie Warriors led by my main man Tom Sestak. Kansas City will gain 11 yards rushing in the first half on 9 attempts. Sestak sheds blocks, and takes down runners, and has the motivated tough-minded teammates to help him. 

During the second half Curtis McClinton reels off a 30-yard run, otherwise, the Chiefs gain 29 yards on 12 attempts. Buffalo has the lead when Len Dawson attempts a screen pass on a first and ten play from his own twenty-yard line. To quote Big Ses . . ."I read their set up and smelled a screen pass so I drifted over to the right". Sestak intercepts and trundles into the end zone to score on his 15-yard return. Fourth quarter and Dawson completes a pass to Jerrel Wilson (yes he did play some running back), and Wilson fumbles win hit, and the recovery is by Tom. Last Kansas City series Sestak takes down Dawson twice to finish with 3 sacks. Name the last defender who recorded 3 sacks, a fumble recovery, an interception return for a touchdown, and you can even add his two tackles for loss on McClinton running plays. Len Dawson is simply quoted "that . . .Sestak", and Red Miller scouting for Denver stated that coach Jack Faulkner "(W)ould trade his entire coaching staff " for Sestak. 

Monday, September 14, 2020

Ball-Hogging Packers Prevail in Minnesota

By Eric Goska

Matt LaFleur, shown here in 2019, joined Phil Bengtson
as the only Packers head coaches to win their first two
NFL season openers. (photo by Eric Goska)

So, what possessed the Green Bay Packers in their 100th season opener as a professional football organization?

How about a remarkable disinclination to share the football?

If possession is nine-tenths of the law, the Packers did their darndest to achieve that threshold. In the opening 30 minutes, more often than not, the offense on the field was adorned in green and gold.

Green Bay parlayed its early edge in time of possession into a 43-34 victory over the Vikings at U.S. Bank Stadium Sunday. By the time the visitors released their stranglehold on the ball, they had wrested control of the game.

Kickoff 2020 was unlike any of the 99 before it. With preseason games canceled and training camp shortened because of a global pandemic, more unknowns than usual accompanied the Packers into the opener.

But if this first outing is any indication, Green Bay remains dangerous offensively, Aaron Rodgers is not ready to abdicate his quarterback spot any time soon, and Davante Adams continues to be one of the best receivers in the NFL.

That potent offense, combined with a three defensive stops, allowed the Packers to dominate time of possession in the first half. The 22 minutes, 45 seconds they extracted was the most on the road by the team in any regular-season game over the last 45 years.

In the opening two quarters, Rodgers and the offense ran 44 plays to the Vikings’ 17. That difference of plus-27 is the fourth highest by the team since 1954.

Green Bay averaged over five-and-a-half minutes on its first four possessions. Then, to showcase its quick-strike ability, Rodgers hit Marquez Valdes-Scantling from 45 yards out to cap a two-play, 11-second drive that put the team up 22-7 just before halftime.

Eight players contributed first downs in the first half: Davante Adams (6), Jamaal Williams (3), Josiah Deguara, Tyler Ervin, Aaron Jones, Allen Lazard, Rodgers and Valdes-Scantling. Vikings’ penalties provided three other first downs.

Minnesota, too, looked unstoppable early. It marched 60 yards to a touchdown in eight plays the first time it had the ball.

But Green Bay shut down the Vikings’ next three advances. Jaire Alexander dumped Kirk Cousins for a safety on a cornerback blitz midway through the second quarter, Za’Darius Smith sacked Cousins to end another drive, and Alexander stifled a third by intercepting a pass intended for Adam Thielen.

All told, the Vikings ran just seven plays over that span.

Though Dan Bailey tacked on a 35-yard field goal as the second quarter expired, Minnesota never got closer than nine in the second half.

Possessing the ball for 20 minutes or more in the first half on the road is a rarity for the Packers. They’ve done it 13 times since 1975 and their record in those games is 9-3-1.

The team’s previous high of 22:23 came in Jacksonville in 1995. Green Bay prevailed 24-14 while gaining 322 yards.

Holding the ball so long, so early set the stage for a number of records.

  • Adams’ 14 reception tied Don Huston’s team record set against the Giants in 1942.
  • Rodger’s 4 TD passes gave him 27 in season openers pushing him past the 24 of previous leader Brett Favre.
  • Green Bay’s 522 yards of offense snapped the previous opening-day haul of 484 in a 37-34 overtime win against the Falcons in 2002.
  • The 43 points by the Packers was an opening-day best, one more than the club registered in a 42-34 conquest of the Saints in 2011.

The Packers outpossessed the Vikings in the second half as well. They held the ball for 18:31 compared to 11:29 for their hosts.

That, however, didn’t preclude Minnesota from forging ahead. Held to 97 yards in the first half, Cousins and Co. amassed 285 yards and averaged nearly nine yards a play in the second half.

In the fourth quarter alone, the Vikings piled up 188 yards and 24 points.

Those are scary numbers. They should serve as a reminder – are you listening Green Bay? – that no lead is safe in the NFL.

Possessed

Since 1975, regular-season road games in which the Packers held the ball for more than 21 minutes in the first half. TOP = time of possession.

TOP             Opponent             Date                              Result

22:45              Vikings                Sept. 13, 2020            GB won 43-34

22:23              Jaguars                Sept. 24, 1995            GB won 24-14

21:49          Buccaneers             Oct. 12, 1980              GB tied 14-14

21:27              Raiders               Nov. 11, 1990             GB won 29-16

21:02              Vikings               Dec. 17, 2000             GB won 33-28

1939 Jim McMillen NFL All-Time Team

 LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films
Jim McMillen, Bears Guard (1924-1928) 
(Color image by John Turney, PFJ)

PFJ continues this week with another All-Time Team. This one was done in 1939 by Jim McMillen, who played 5 seasons at guard for the Chicago Bears from 1924-1928. He started 66 of 69 career games for the Bears, including many games on the Red Grange 1925-1926 famous barnstorming tour. He was selected First Team All-Pro three times by Chicago Tribune (1926-28) and twice each by Collyers Eye Magazine (1924, 1926) and Green Bay Press-Gazette (1925, 1928). Probably could've played longer but went into pro wrestling.

In 1939 McMillen choose his professional football All-Time Team. Mostly teammate heavy, McMillen selected:

Ends- Don Hutson, Gaynell Tinsley

Tackles- Ed Healey, Link Lyman

Guards- Hunk Anderson, Mike Michalske

Center- Mel Hein

Quarterback- Benny Friedman

Halfbacks- Red Grange, Dutch Clark

Fullback- Bronko Nagurski

 McMillen's biggest surprsies was at end, going away from Bears great Bill Hewitt and selecting Tinsley. He said:

"(Hutson and Tinsley) would have been stars in pro football in any era."

He also thought that Red Grang and Bronko Nagurski were "the two greatest of all-time..."

Brandon Staley's Tweaks of the Rams Defense

 By John Turney

Joseph-Day, Brockers, and Donald  Credit: NBC

The Rams let Wade Phillips go after three years as their defensive coordinator after the 2019 season and singed young up-and-comer, Brandon Daly, as his replacement.

With no preseason games and little reporting from the Los Angeles/Rams media, we could go little sense of what Daly was planning on doing or what changes or impression he was going to make on the Rams defense.

We were told and knew it would remain a base 3-4 defense. Stay was from the Vic Fango coaching tree and Fangio is a 3-4 disciple. 

Other than that, we knew little. 

Last night we got some answers. More will come as Taylor Rapp gets healthy—more on thta later in the post. 

But in addition to the Rams defense doing a solid job in a win over Dallas we know the starters (not announced by NBC's Sunday Night Football) are as follows:

Base 3-4 defense

Rams base 3-4 defenses
3-3 Nickel (5-1 or Penny front)
DE—Michael Brockers
DT—Aaron Donald
NT—Sebastian Joseph-Day
ROLB—Samson Ebukam
LOLB—Leonard Floyd
LB—Micah Kiser
Slot—Troy Hill
CB—Jalen Ramsey
RS—Jordan Fuller
LS—John Johnson III
Rams 3-3 nickel personnel (a 5-1 look)
Nickel 
LE—Leonard Floyd
RE—Ogbonnia Okoronkwo/Samson Ebukam
DT—Michael Brockers
DT—Aaron Donald
WILB—Micah Kiser
SILB—Kenny Young
Slot—Troy Hill
CB—Jalen Ramsey
RS—Jordan Fuller
LS—John Johnson III
Nickel
Nickel on long (i.e. 3rd and 10 et al) distances
LE—Leonard Floyd
RE—Ogbonnia Okoronkwo
DT—Michael Brockers
DT—Aaron Donald
WILB—Micah Kiser
Slot—Troy Hill
CB—Jalen Ramsey
CB—Darious Williams
RS—Jordan Fuller
LS—John Johnson III
"Long nickel/prevent-type" nickel personnel

The front is the same as it was under Phillips with Donald playing 3-technique and Joseph-Day the shade or nose tackle and Brockers is the end or 5-tech. Donald flops from side to side depending on where the tight end or strong side is. Nothing new here so far in terms of where players line up. However, it seems the Rams front they use most is a 3-3 nickel in a 5-1 alignment (Penny front) and they are not one-gapping or two-gapping, they play it soft—a gap-and-a-half, where they really try to just slow runs rather than get one-gap all-out penetration and let the second and third level Calvary arrive. 

In the gap-and-a-half system a player would take his gap and then rather than penetrate too far he'd SQUEEZE the gap next to him. So, he has the B-Gap he would control that gap then he'd push his blocker inside to the A-Gap to help out with that gap, who in theory, is also playing half that gap. The gap-and-a-half players penetrate, but do not shoot, his primary gap, holds and if running back is coming through the gap next to him the secondary gap he tried to pop back and make tackle.

The inside linebackers are Kiser and Young. We only counted a handful of plays the Rams were in base defense. Kiser is the "Will" the weak-side inside 'backer and Young is the strong inside backer. Wade Phillips called it the "Mo" but other coaches call it different things among them "Will". So, as of now, we are calling Young the "strong" inside linebacker because he almost always is on the three-receiver side and when there is motion he follows it, and he and Kiser switch. 

Kiser is usually on the weak or two receiver side and when there is only one linebacker on the field, he is it—Young goes to the bench, exactly like Cory Littleton last year when he stayed on the field and Reeder (and before him Hager) went to the sidelines in sub defenses. We are curious as to whether there are more reads we are not aware of. Most often the tight end is on the three-receiver side, making Young the "SILB" or "money 'backer" but we will follow this for a few weeks to make sure we have it down. Often the bigger, stouter linebacker is the strong-side guy and the smaller, quicker inside 'backer in the weakside guy, but this seems to defy that tradition. It also looks like the inside backers could play on a certain side game-to-game rather than always on the strong or weak side.

But playing into that tradition is that Kiser is usually in the middle of the field and Young shades to the tight end, making him, perhaps, more of a "Sam" type nickel 'backer. Again, we will see what happens in Philadelphia and Buffalo and update this post then. So, we'll wait and see if Kiser emerges as the "Mike" depending on the reads we see. As of Week 1, we're going with the three-receiver side being the strong side, but of course, Staley may have something else as his key. 

"Wait", you say, "'Will' is the weakside outside backer". No, not in this scheme. The outside linebackers do not flop sides (change sides based on where the tight end lines up), they line up left and right. Floyd is the left outside linebacker and Ebukam is the right outside linebacker. This is new.

Under Phillips, one linebacker was the "Sam" the other was the "Will". The Will was a defacto defensive end in the "Will Weak" under front Phillips used most of the time. He rushed most of the time and had a run fit. The Sam would rush some, cover some depending on the call. 

Players like Robert Quinn or Dante Fowler rarely dropped into coverage—they were the Wills in the Phillips schemes.

Apparently, Daley will have his outside linebackers, in base anyway, skilled in playing with a tight end in front of him and without. This is akin to what Fritz Shurmur did from 1983-90, the last time the Rams ran a base 3-4. Then, Mel Owens, then later Kevin Greene, were left linebackers, and first George Andrews, and then Mike Wilcher were the right outside linebackers. 

If a tight end were in front of them they'd squat with hands in front of them ready to jam the tight end to interfere with his release. If there was not a tight end in front of then they'd have the inside foot forward and were in a rush position. 

Of course, in nickel and then the Eagle/Hawk things changed in the 1980s Rams defenses but that is a conversation for another day.

So, with left- and right outside linebackers they can both play roles, depending on where their nickelback is. So in one instance, Floyd can rush and the opposite OLBer can drop or vice versa meaning either one can be a "Jack" backer—the linebacker that is opposite of the nickelback. It would seem this can be a way to disuse the defense to some degree. 

The Rams showed Cover-2/4 or a two-deep look almost all of the time but played it Cover-2/4 very little with one of the safeties "robbing" or rotating into the box. They mostly played match quarters or cover-6 among some other things we need to study more. The played their cornerbacks "off" at around eight yards much of the time as well, apparently to allow them to play out of phase and break to the ball to break up passes.

The corners for the Rams moved around, Ramsey was on both sides, sometimes following Cooper we will see if that continues during the season.

Most interesting were the safeties. Johnson III was the left safety and Fuller was the right safety. They were not strong and weak. One of the safeties didn't follow the tight end or go to the three-receiver side (the strong side). They stayed on their side. Usually, they showed a two-deep look, then rotated with Fuller often going deep middle and Johnson III lurking or "robbing"—coming up to make plays closer to the line of scrimmage, but of course, not all the time which is the advantage of playing left- and right- as opposed to strong and weak. Against Dallas, especially early in the game, Fuller was in the box almost as much as Johnson III, though we didn't do a count. This, of course, could change and we will take notes in the upcoming weeks. 

This is uncommon, but not unheard of—Fango and defensive coordinator Ed Donatell ran it that way in Denver in 2019 for example but you have to look hard to find examples. The duo of Fangio and Donatell (as defensive coordinator and defensive back coach respectively) when they were previously with the Bears and 49ers together deployed their safeties in the traditional strong and free alignment.

The last time the Rams did this was in 1983 preseason with Johnnie Johnson and Nolan Cromwell. But by week one of the season Cromwell (because he made so many good plays covering tight ends) was just moved to strong safety and Johnson to free safety. The plan was to go left- and right- but Rams coaches just thought switching them to strong and weak was better for the scheme so that is what they did rather than follow the "plan". The previous three seasons Cromwell was the free safety and Johnson was the strong safety. It got discombobulated in 1984 when both Johnson (early in the season) and Cromwell (late in the season) got injured and both were free safeties that year. But in 1985 they were back to Cromwell strong and Johnson free.

In 1986 and 1987 the Rams used a three safety rotation with Cromwell, Johnson, and Vince Newsome. but that is also a conversation for another time but in general, when Cromwell and Johnson were in the game Cromwell was strong and Johnson was weak. When Newsome and Cromwell were in Newsome was strong and Cromwell free and when Johnson and Newsome were in Johnson was free and Newsome was strong. 

Prior to the 1983 preseason, one would have to go back to the early 1960s to find left- and right safeties likely 1961. Since 1962 (possibly 1961-still checking) or so they had been going strong/free until 2020.
Lindon Crow #41, likely the rams first strong safety as opposed to "left" safety—1963
Strong and free safeties came about in the NFL when teams began to use tight ends full time and that was in the early 1960s. Prior to that teams still would use three backs (one motioning to the slot or to the flank) or three ends, one of them in the slot or sometimes one "tight". But it was varied. Both safties were expected to be able to handle any situations, whether there was a big-man tight on their side or if they were on the three-receiver side or the two-receiver side.

But as the tight ends got bigger and used more often, in the early 1960s, coaches countered with having one safety always on the tight end or three-receiver side and the other om the weak side, being "free" to cover the middle zone, double-team a particularly tough end, blitz (think Larry Wilson), or lurk or "rob" in the middle of the defense—lots of things. 

Strong safeties were bigger, stronger, and able to cover tight ends, but also to force run plays inside by taking on blocks of pulling offensive linemen and tackle fullbacks. So the skill sets grew apart over time. 

In recent years the skill sets are closer, but even so, rarely do coaches play safeties exclusively left and right for a whole game in both base and nickel. For whatever reason, coaches stick to strong and weak or one safety who is a 'box' safety and another who is more of a MOF-type "middle of the field" safety. Not always, of course, some safeties are excellent at both, they can cover, man or zone, play in the box, blitz, tackle, have great range, but that is not all of them. So, coaches have to make choices. 

So, it was interesting to watch last night, twin safeties, not a common thing. We will know more about the coverages when the All-22 comes out tomorrow but it was kind of a treat to see this tactic deployed.

Also of note, John Johnson III is the player receiving the defensive play calls, presumably from Staley—he has the green dot on his helmet rather than Kiser, the every-down linebacker which does happen, a safety taking the plays, but it's not common.
John Johnson III with the "green dot" 
And kudos to rookie Jordan Fuller. Not only was he the starter he had to play both techniques, the strong and weak depending on which was the strong side. And though he did seemingly miss a tackle early in the contest he did make the defensive play of the game when he made a fourth-down tackle stopping a Dallas drive that potentially could have given the Cowboys the lead. 
Fuller makes 4th and one tackle
We like Taylor Rapp a lot, but he missed time in camp and never got his starting job back. He only played in the 3rd and really long packages, and on the final drive in addition to special teams. When he was in he was a linebacker in the nickel, and on a couple of plays he played left safety with Johnson dropping into the linebacker spot in that "long nickel" package. 

Time will tell if he can supplant Kenny Young as the WILL in the nickel which, really, is a starters position, or if he can move the rookie Jordan Fuller out of the right safety positions. Fuller looked good. Johnson III played some linebacker in sub defenses last year under Phillips so it is possible he could do some of the same with Rapp playing left safety but this is all speculation. All we know is Rapp is a high draft choice who missed a lot of reps in camp and only had a role in really, prevent defenses in game one—along with special teams and that is not why he was drafted so high.

But McStaley (McVay and Staley) is going to play who earns the spot so the onus is on Rapp. 

We will keep readers posted on other changes we see in the Rams scheme as we look at more film.