Wagner and David: The Unsung Tackle Masters Climbing the NFL Record Books
by Nick Webster
In the world of NFL statistics, Touchdowns, Yards, Reception, and on the defensive side Sacks and Interceptions dominate the headlines. But quietly, two veteran linebackers are making history in a category that rarely gets the spotlight - tackles. Tampa Bay Buccaneers' Lavonte David and Washington Commanders' Bobby Wagner are rapidly ascending the all-time tackles leaderboard as they prepare for the 2025 season – a remarkable achievement that deserves proper recognition.The Complicated History of Tackle Statistics
Before celebrating these modern-day tackling machines, we must understand why the all-time tackle leaderboard remains problematic. Despite being fundamental to defensive performance, tackles still aren't considered an official NFL statistic. The tracking of tackles has evolved dramatically over the decades, creating significant challenges when comparing players across eras.
Since 1999, the NFL has maintained consistent standards for recording tackles in its official league play-by-plays with weekly reviews and adjustments. This rigorous process ensures tackles are credited accurately and consistently league-wide. Prior to 1999, tackle statistics become increasingly questionable the further back you look.
From roughly 1980-1998, play-by-play crews increasingly maintained consistency, but team-reported numbers often differed significantly. The 1970s saw tackle statistics become more widespread and available but with notable inconsistencies even in the official league play-by-plays. Documents best characterized as federated system pulling together individual team play-by-plays, with meaningful differences depending on the local stat-crews. Before 1970, tackle statistics were largely unreliable.
Understanding Tackle Eras
To properly contextualize David and Wagner's achievements, we must recognize distinct "tackle eras":
1. Modern Era (1999-present): Highly reliable play-by-play numbers with official review procedures
2. Alignment Era (1980-1998): Generally consistent play-by-play data, though not subject to today's review standards
3. Early Recording Era (1970-1980): Play-by-play data exists but requires skepticism
4. Pre-Historic Era (pre-1970): No reliable standardized recording
The subjective nature of tackles created significant disparities between team-reported and press box numbers. Teams often inflated tackle statistics, particularly in the 1970s, when stars like Randy Gradishar, Bill Bergey, and Harry Carson would be credited with 200+ tackles by their teams while press box figures showed more modest (though still impressive) totals in the high 100s.
Wagner and David: The Modern Tackle Titans
What makes Bobby Wagner and Lavonte David's climb up the tackle leaderboard so impressive is the era in which they've played. Their numbers come from the modern era of consistent, reviewed tackle statistics. Unlike some historical figures whose numbers may be inflated, Wagner and David's totals represent authentic defensive production under standardized counting protocols.
While Ray Lewis and London Fletcher, two other tackle legends, also benefited from playing primarily in the modern era, Wagner and David continue to climb and demonstrate remarkable longevity and consistency. Their ascent through the ranks is unquestionable in its legitimacy.
As they prepare for the 2025 season, both linebackers continue to defy age, consistently racking up tackles with the same efficiency they've shown throughout their careers. With each solo tackle and assist, they cement their legacy as two of the greatest defenders of their generation.
The Numbers Don't Lie: Elite Company
When we focus exclusively on play-by-play tackle data—the most reliable measure—Wagner and David currently rank fourth and seventh all-time, respectively. The elite top 10 consists of all-time leader Ray Lewis (2,059), London Fletcher, Junior Seau, Bobby Wagner, Zach Thomas, Derrick Brooks, Lavonte David, Leroy Jordan, Harry Carson, and Hardy Nickerson.
Rk Name 1st Season Last Seas TT Per Yr Per 17 G
1 Ray Lewis 1996 2012 2,059 121 154
2 London Fletcher 1998 2013 2,039 127 135
3 Jr. Seau 1990 2009 1,920 96 122
4 Bobby Wagner 2012 2024 1,838 141 155
5 Zach Thomas 1996 2008 1,735 133 160
6 Derrick Brooks 1995 2008 1,709 122 130
7 Lavonte David 2012 2024 1,601 123 137
8 Lee Roy Jordan 1963 1976 1,538 110 140
9 Harry Carson 1976 1988 1,528 118 150
10 Hardy Nickerson 1987 2002 1,507 94 114
This list notably excludes several players who frequently appear in tackle discussions but benefited from inflated team statistics. Jesse Tuggle, often credited with 2,065 tackles, registered only 1,370 in play-by-play accounts. Randy Gradishar's team-reported 2,000+ tackles shrink to 1,332 when using play-by-play data. Even Steve Nelson's patriotic 1,776 tackles (see what they did there!) cited by New England falls to 1,475 in actual play-by-play documentation.
What about iconic linebackers like Dick Butkus and Jack Lambert? Despite their legendary status, shorter careers and injuries kept them from reaching the statistical heights of the top ten. Even using team numbers, Butkus logged just 1,460 tackles—and team figures typically exceed play-by-play counts. Pre-1970 greats like Joe Schmidt, Sam Huff, and Bill George likely reached around 1,500 tackles based on limited available data, but almost certainly fell short of the 2,000 milestone.
Impact Beyond Numbers
What truly separates David and Wagner from many others is the quality of their tackles. Ray Lewis, the all-time leader, recorded 117 stuffs (tackles for loss or minimal gain in the backfield). Junior Seau leads this category with 171 stuffs. But London Fletcher, despite his 2,000+ tackles, managed just 70 stuffs.
Lavonte David stands second only to Seau with 140 stuffs—demonstrating his remarkable playmaking ability. Wagner continues climbing this list with 78 stuffs and will likely surpass 80 in the coming season as he’s still stuffing runners at a solid clip for his age logging 9 in each of the past two seasons. A little football IQ can make up for a lost step or two.
As we witness the final chapters of these two all-time great linebackers' careers, their Hall of Fame credentials are undeniable. While David's time in Tampa Bay may create challenges for his Canton case due to some underperforming Buccaneers teams, voters would be wise to focus on the film and the numbers—both of which clearly demonstrate that David along with Wagner belong among the immortals of the game.