Monday, May 16, 2016

1975-1985 All-Mid-Decade Teams

By John Turney

A couple of months ago we chose a  2005-2015 All-Mid-Decade Teams and a 1995-2005 team as well as  1985-95  to represent the best players from that era, realizing that just an All-Decade team that began in 1960, 1970, 1980, etc., was a bit arbitrary.

Now, here is our 1975-1985 All-Decade team:
This is the perfect decade for Webster as he was a starter for the first time in 1975 and was dominant for the next decade. In the 1980s, Dwight Stephenson had a higher peak and some experts felt he was the top center for the 1980s over Webby. The Second-team selection was close, but Van Note gets the nod, with Rich Saul and Jack Rudnay as honorable mentions.
Mike Webster. Credit: Merv Corning
Hannah and DeLamielleure are like Webster, these 10 years are THEIR ten years. Backups are Keuch and Ed White, who had a good second stop in San Diego after a good bit of time in Minnesota. Herb Scott of the Cowboys, though, along with Dennis Harrah of the Rams deserve honorable mentions.
John Hannah. Credit Merv Corning
Joe DeLamielleure. Credit: Chuck Ren
The tackles are harder in that these players were not players who excelled in all ten yearssome of them exiting after 1982 and some beginning in 1978. The 1970s and 1980s had tackles who had careers that fit those ten-year periods, here, it's partial decades. But the best were Marvin Powell, who was dominant for a few years, but tailed off, and Leon Gray (who also tailed of some). Kenn was a rookie in 1978 but was a great tackle through the rest of this mid-decade span. Russ Washington was an underrated guy for the 1970s team but was good in the late-1970s and early 1980s as well. Doug France is an honorable mention. Larry Brown, the Steelers converted tight end is also worthy of a mention here. Henry Lawrence is also an honorable mention. He was kind of a scapegoat in 1978 when Ken Stabler blamed him for "not playing well" but that was his second season as a starter and he did get better. After all, he was a Pro Bowler and was a starter on two Super Bowl-winning teams.
Russ Washington. Credit: Chuck Ren
Dave Casper did his best work in the 1975-85 span as did Second-teamer Russ Francis. Kellen Winslow broke a leg in 1979 and was only a starter from 1980-85. Due to his shorter tenure (and Ozzie Newsome, too), they regulated to the 1980s All-Decade Teams where their careers fit more nicely. It is a close call but Casper and Francis were fine blockers and good receivers as well. They didn't put up the numbers of Newsome or Casper, but they could block much better. 
Dave Casper. Credit: Merv Corning
Dan Fouts has all the honors and states in this decade. Ken Anderson is next. But, we were tempted to go with Terry Bradshaw, who won 3 Super Bowls in this decade (as opposed to 4 in the 1970s where he was snubbed on most 1970s All-Decade teams) and was an MVP as well. He gets an honorable mention as does Joe Theismann.

Dan Fouts, Ken Anderson, and Terry Bradshaw. Credit: Merv Corning
We mentioned that Earl Campbell was a Second-team All-Decade in the 1970s but didn't deserve it. Well, here he does. And he's right there with Walter Payton, who like Webster and Hannah did amazing things in this mid-decade. Tony Dorsett and John Riggins are the Second-team running backs.
Walter Payton. Credit: Merv Corning
Earl Campbell. Credit: Merv Corning

Tony Dorsett. Credit: Merv Corning
John Riggins. Credit: Merv Corning
Wide receivers, as always, are hard in this type of exercise because people of good faith have varying criteria in what they see in a wide receiver and we anticipate that we will get some grief for our selections. We are going with James Lofton and Lynn Swann on the First-team. Lofton for his deep threat ability and Swann for the same reasons he's in the Hall of Fame, i.e. big plays when they mattered most. 

On the Second-team we are going with John Jefferson, who was simply great with the Chargers and then traded away, but at his peak, he was one of the great ones as an "X" receiver in the Coryell system. John Stallworth and Drew Pearson share the other spot. Pearson is the NFC's answer to Lynn Swann and his 1974-83 and his exploits in post-season made it impossible to leave off. We give Charlie Joiner an honorable mention and Wes Chandler, who also excelled as an "X" receiver in Air Coryell after Jefferson was traded to Green Bay. Clearly, Steve Largent is a strong honorable mention, but we felt he was a bit more of a 1980s guy and we factored in team success and big plays in playoff games.
John Stallworth. Credit Merv Corning

Lynn Swann. Credit Merv Corning
Drew Pearson. Credit: Merv Corning
James Lofton. Credit: Chuck Ren
Lee Roy Selmon is a Hall of Famer and this is the decade in which he played, 1975-85, the 1970s only 4 years and in the 1980s he played 5 years. He was a Defensive Player of the Year and won multiple NFLPA NFC Lineman of the Year Awards. The other end is Jack Youngblood who, during this mid-decade, was All-Pro four times, Second-team All-Pro twice and had 113 sacks from 1975-84. 
Lee Roy Selmon. Credit:  Cliff Spohn
Jack Youngblood. Credit: Marv Corning
The Second-team defensive ends are Fred Dean and Harvey Martin. Dean was the UPI NFC Defensive Player of the Year in 1981 and helped the 49ers to two Super Bowl wins. Martin was a great blind-side rusher and was the Defensive Player of the Year in 1977 and 99 sacks from 1975-83. Honorable mentions are Lyle Alzado, Joe Kelcko, and Ed Jones.
Fred Dean. Credit: Cliff Spohn
Harvey Martin. Credit: Merv Corning
At tackle Randy White is the "natural" for this mid-decade team. Gary Johnson is the other tackle. Dave Butz as one backup and nose tackle Bob Baumhower narrowly edges Doug English, who is an honorable mention. Louis Kelcher started off as a player who seemed like he'd be the next Merlin Olsen but after 1982 he just wasn't up to snuff. But from 1975-81 he was making a lot of plays behind the line of scrimmage, sacks and stuffs, like Olsen used to do.
Randy White. Credit: Merv Corning
Inside backers are easy, Jack Lambert and Randy Gradishar. Steve Nelson and Harry Carson are the Second-teamers but Lambert and Gradishar are way ahead in terms of All-Pros, Defensive Player of the Year Awards and Pro Bowls. 
Jack Lambert.  Credit: Merv Corning

Randy Gradishar. Credit. Cliff Spohn
Ted Hendricks got a nod on the 1980s All-Decade team but played only four years of the 1980s and we don't feel he belonged on that team. But, he belongs here. Robert Brazile does as well. Matt Blair and Brad Van Pelt are very good Second-teamers on this squad.
Ted Hendricks. Credit: Merv Corning
Brad Van Pelt  Credit: Alain Moreau
Mel Blount ranks first, and we have Mike Haynes and Louis Wright tied for second. Blount was excellent through his final season of 1983. Haynes and Wright were so close it was impossible to separate them. Both were 6-2, smooth coverage men. Wright was a little better on run support, and Haynes had better hands. 
Mel Blount. Credit: Merv Corning

Mike Haynes. Credit: Merv Corning
Backing them up are Gary Green and in another tie, Lester Hayes and Ken Riley as the Second-teamers. Hayes and Riley got all their "awards" in this 1975-85 period.

Donnie Shell is the strong safety and Nolan Cromwell the free. Tim Fox and Gary Fencik. We may be shorting Gary Barbaro a bit, as he had some big years, but since the decade includes 1985, we went Fencik. The same is true of Johnnie Gray who was a top-rated safety by Proscout, Inc. in the late-1970s and early 1980s. He was an excellent free and strong safety so we give him an honorable mention along with Gary Barbaro
Donnie Shell. Credit: Cliff Spohn
Nolan Cromwell. Credit: John Turney
Mosely and Stenerud are the kickers and they are the guys with the most "Alls" and were good on their percentages. The returners are based on touchdowns and All-pros more than average, but all here are tops in that category as well.
Jan Stenrud. Credit: Merv Corning
J.T. Smith is an honorable mention returner as is Freddie Solomon, who are behind Upchurch and Johnson and Clayborn and Payton.

Hank Bauer was the NFL Alumni Special Teams Player of the Year a couple times and had a monster 1981 season with 52 credited tackles. Ivory Sully of the Rams and Jeff Barnes of the Raiders were guys who covered from gunner positions, blocked on returns, and were great kick blockers, both of punts and placements. We had to include both on the Second-team. Mosi Tatupu gets an honorable mention. (He would be on our 1980s team as the core special teamer)

Agree or disagree? Post in the comments section below.

1 comment:

  1. The portrait illustration of Brad Van Pelt is by Alain A Moreau