Saturday, May 6, 2023

The Baltimore Colts' Answer to the 49ers' Shotgun—Use Big Daddy as a Cover Linebacker

 By John Turney 

In 1960 49ers coach Red Hickey introduced his "shotgun" formation in late November against the Baltimore Colts in Memorial Stadium.

Interestingly the TV announcers called it the "double wing" and one paper called it a "Freakish Spread" but Hickey called it the shotgun. 

Hickey's reasoning was that his steam could not match the strength of the Colts, "Standing out there on a straight T, charging toe-to-toe with the Colts can be suicide. So I gambled that the formation - I call it 'the shotgun' - would go, figuring we had the right people to operate it."

John Brodie was the "right person" and then Bob Watters who finished the game was a "right person", too as the 49ers won 30-22. 

The shotgun had been around a long time, but teams didn't use it much through the 1940s and 1950s. However you can see examples of it, but the 49ers made it work in beating the World Champion Colts.

What was interesting is the counter the Colts used to defend it.

They'd shift their usual 4-3 defense to a 3-4 on the fly - now they'd call it stemming - and they would have Big Daddy Lipscomb, their defensive tackle, play inside linebacker - even covering a zone downfield.

When the 49ers came up to the line of scrimmage and the Colts would be in their usual 4-man front and if the 49ers shifted to the shotgun Bid Daddy would move to left inside linebacker and the middle linebacker would move to the right inside position. 

Here you can see the shift and the big defensive tackle drop into a hook/curl zone and even make a play on the ball. After the play, you can see big #76 get up and walk in front of the screen.

Here is another example, this was not an interception it was ruled incomplete but at the end of the play Big Daddy gave a shot to a 49er—

If the 49ers remained in a pro 4-3 set the Colts would stay in the pro 4-3 (often called a 6-1 now)—

Other teams followed suit. Here is a clip of the Rams doing a similar shift. However, they chose to move right defensive end Lamar Lundy to the right inside linebacker position and the middle linebacker, Les Richter moved to the left inside 'backer spot—

Back to Lipscomb. 

In that era, he could be seen as an inside linebacker in a 3-4 defense on occasion against usual spilt-back formations. He'd play right inside linebacker, using his sideline-to-sideline range to chase down
running plays, mostly. It was tantamount to a stand-up defensive tackle.

Here is one shot of that, also from 1960—

But this alignment wasn't just a "BigDaddy" thing, whoever the right tackle was would sometimes step off the line. Here it is Don Joyce who is spelling Lipscomb doing a similar thing—

Prior to joining the Colts, Lipscomb was a Ram and once in a while (not much) they'd run a 3-4 but they put him at nose tackle (then called middle guard), not as a linebacker—


With the Colts he'd play nose-in in the nickel/prevent defense—

The 6-6, 285-pound (300-plus pound?) could move for a big man and the Colts' coaches took advantage of his athleticism to play him off-the-ball.

Playing on the nose in an over or undershift (not shown) or in a 3-man nickel or a 3-4 like he did with the Rams is to be expected. Countless defensive tackles did that.

Few men his size could drop to a spot, pick up the receiver in his zone and defend the pass.

The Bid Daddy could.

True, the 49ers won the initial "shotgun game" but it was kind of a fluke. On the play, Big Daddy was in coverage and the initial play was stopped but Dee Mackey lateraled to R.C. Owens and he took it into the end zone, chased by Lipscomb.

It proved to be the game-winner.
So, score the win for Hickey and the shotgun but also give some credit to the Colts for trying something creative—a (likely) 300-pound cover linebacker.

8 comments:

  1. Never saw this footage before. Gene Lipscomb is Hall of Fame player. Being snubbed.

    ReplyDelete
  2. BW ...

    Jim will like the idea of Big Daddy in zone coverage. Talented or not, with underrated Ray Krouse playing quality minutes along the defensive interior, Lipscomb just isnt getting the push he needs to make the Hall.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Brian, I presume by "the push he needs" you are referring to voter support as opposed to a possible "inability" to move an offensive lineman backwards..};->

      Delete
  3. BW ...

    A fateful game indeed because had the Colts won and had theyre record at 7-2, they might have won their third western division in a row. Instead, they start a four game losing streak that gives the division to GB and infuriates Carroll Rosenbloom, who I felt never thought the Packers would rise to prominance. All due to a heads up play by Dee Mackey.

    At least the Niners shotgun formation looked like todays
    version and not the punting-type formation that Dawson and the Chiefs used in early 1967 to embarrass the Bears in an exhibition game.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're right, the wheels came off Baltimore after that game this was a big loss.

      Delete
  4. BW ...

    Thanks for showing this primitive broadcast footage of the game, I havent watched in awhile.
    Can you imagine watching Gino Marchetti, Del Shofner or Lenny Moore all the time on tv? Back then, the cameras could barely keep up with the action. Thank goddess for instant replay and other innovations--many coming from Roone Arledge with ABC--too bad television coverage didnt implement what Ed Sabol always advocated; showing endzone angles of the action from the players point of view at the line of scrimmage. CBS did more of that type of coverage going into the 90s but not a lot live, mostly to support replay or player isolation ... with zooming, fans can see more live isolation or certain areas of the field.

    ReplyDelete
  5. thanks John for this deep dive into an aspect of Big Daddy's arsenal that's usually overlooked.
    1. for some reason YouTube has removed the 1960 49ers highlight film (although kept most others from that era), but this game features prominently (for good 49er reason)....you mention Bobby Watters...I'm guessing he finished the game after (as 10:21 on that clip shows)....Big Daddy, after creeping back like a giant cat just prior to the snap of the ball, drops back deep, Brodie scrambles on a broken play for about 15 yard pickup and Big Daddy almost takes his head off with a clothesline club to John's helmet...YOUCH!...if you've got that clip, would be great to have it published on the Journal.
    2. appreciate that you appreciate Lipscomb's talent....it remains one of my great disappointments that Gene is not in the HoF. One would presume that the "Terrell Davis" rule would apply 100%....considered by his peers to be unstoppable, he is one of the few personalities in the history of the game to have become "legendary"...throughout nfl fandom, Big Daddy was one of the most prominent and popular personalities of the era....although it's been 6 decades, every few years some publication does a "Big Daddy" feature....while his all-pro and pro bowl accumulations do not standout, his truncated career should not be held against him....one wonders how in 1961 this guy, an interior lineman ran down qbs for 17.5 sacks (in 14 games!) and somehow wasn't picked for the East pro bowl team. The fact that he was a finalist for the Centenary 100 team but not in the Hall remains a stunning and inexplicable oversight.
    3. as Brian points out, that 6-2 Colts game resulting in 6-3 beginning of the tailspin starts the confluence of events that keeps Baltimore from the 3-peat that should have happened....a star-crossed squad, the following week is the Lions game with Ameche tearing his achilles and that insane Earl Morrall hitting Jim Gibbons for the game-ending td one play after Unitas drops a dime to a horizontal Lenny Moore behind NightTrain...then the usually fatal Colt west coast swing...1960. 64 title game, 65 playoff game, 67 Rams game and 1/12/69 STILL hurt.

    ReplyDelete
  6. He was a defensive tackle, though. Most of all.

    ReplyDelete