By Chris Willis, NFL Films
![]() |
| Jimmy Conzleman |
By John Turney
Over the past couple of years, Chris Willis of NFL Films and author of several essential books on the early NFL has posted the All-time teams as chosen by many of the All-Time greats such as Don Hutson, Johnny Blood, Sammy Baugh, and others. Willis even has his own team, based on his heavily-researched series of the top players in the pre-WWII era.
For comparison purposes here is a chart of all those teams. We think it is a fair representation of the consensus of those teams and gives readers unfamiliar with that era who the best players of that era were. 
![]() |
Top row—Center: Mel Hein, Guards Dan Fortmann and Mike Michalske Bottom row—Tackles: Cal Hubbard, Turk Edwards, Joe Stydahar, and Link Lyman (votes for tackle very close) |
![]() |
| Top row—Ends: Bill Hewitt and Don Hutson Bottom row—T QB: Sammy Baugh; Single Wing TB: Dutch Clark |
![]() |
| Top Row—Fullback Bronko Nagurski; Blocking back Father Lumpkin; Halback Red Grange Second row—Halfhback George McAfee; Halfback Cliff Battles, HB-FB Clark Hinkle Bottom— Halfback Steve Van Buen |
Steve Van Buren is sort of an anomy because he played mostly after World War II and he got four votes, one more than Grange and Hinkle and the same as McAfee. Like the voting for the tackles, it was too close to call. So you can make up your mind as to who you want in your backfield.
Today, PFJ will take a look at the NFL All-Time Team by the great Don Hutson. In 1948, just three years after retiring from the Packers as a player, Hutson gave the Green Bay Press-Gazette his All-Time Team of players he played against. He included five players from the rival Chicago Bears, and maybe one surprise be naming Giants end Jim Poole.
Hutson choose:
Ends- Bill Hewitt, Jim Poole
Tackles- Turk Edwards, George Christensen
Guards- Dan Fortmann, Riley Matheson
Center- Bulldog Turner
Quarterback- Sid Luckman
Halfbacks- Cliff Battles, Steve Van Buren
Fullback- Bronko Nagurski
![]() |
| (Source: Green Bay Press-Gazette, Nov. 24, 1948) |
![]() |
| Johnny "Blood" McNally, Packers |
Today PFJ looks at the NFL All-Time Team from Johnny "Blood" McNally. In 1944 McNally was asked to list his all-time team. He praised Don Hutson, so much that he listed 3 ends on his team.
One of his biggest surprise was that he selected Father Lumpkin as his blocking back (or quarterback spot). McNally choose:
Ends- Don Hutson, Bill Hewitt, Brick Mueller
Tackles- Cal Hubbard, Pete "Fats" Henry
Guards- Mike Michalske, Dan Fortmann
Center- Mel Hein
Quarterback-Blocking Back- Father Lumpkin
Halfbacks- Dutch Clark (LHB), Sammy Baugh (RHB)
Fullback- Bronko Nagurski
![]() |
| (Source: Marshfield News-Herald, Aug. 4, 1944) |
![]() |
| Jim McMillen, Bears Guard (1924-1928) (Color image by John Turney, PFJ) |
PFJ continues this week with another All-Time Team. This one was done in 1939 by Jim McMillen, who played 5 seasons at guard for the Chicago Bears from 1924-1928. He started 66 of 69 career games for the Bears, including many games on the Red Grange 1925-1926 famous barnstorming tour. He was selected First Team All-Pro three times by Chicago Tribune (1926-28) and twice each by Collyers Eye Magazine (1924, 1926) and Green Bay Press-Gazette (1925, 1928). Probably could've played longer but went into pro wrestling.
In 1939 McMillen choose his professional football All-Time Team. Mostly teammate heavy, McMillen selected:
Ends- Don Hutson, Gaynell Tinsley
Tackles- Ed Healey, Link Lyman
Guards- Hunk Anderson, Mike Michalske
Center- Mel Hein
Quarterback- Benny Friedman
Halfbacks- Red Grange, Dutch Clark
Fullback- Bronko Nagurski
McMillen's biggest surprsies was at end, going away from Bears great Bill Hewitt and selecting Tinsley. He said:
"(Hutson and Tinsley) would have been stars in pro football in any era."
He also thought that Red Grang and Bronko Nagurski were "the two greatest of all-time..."
![]() |
| Tuffy Leemans, number 4, ball carrier for Giants vs Packers Color image courtesy of John Turney, PFJ |
QB- Sammy Baugh
HB- Dutch Clark
HB- Cliff Battles
FB- Bronko Nagurski
Leemans had high praise for Sammy Baugh, saying:
"Baugh is the best passer and the best football player of all-time. He's the finest thing that ever happened to pro football."
![]() |
| Paul Robeson |
As the NFL's 101st season kicks off tonight PFJ takes another look back at some of the game's greatest players. Last season the NFL celebrated its 100th All-Time Team. PFJ listed several former coaches and players All-Time choices last season and will post a few more to celebrate this season's opening week.
Today we feature Paul Robeson's All-Time team from 1941. Robeson, a former Rutgers all-american end, played just 2 seasons in the NFL with the 1921 Akron Pros and 1922 Milwaukee Badgers. He retired from pro football to pursue a successful career as a singer and actor.
As for his All-Time Team he selected the following:
Ends: Larry Kelley, Brick Muller
Guards: Gus Sonnenberg, Bronko Nagurski
Tackles: Duke Slater, Pete "Fats" Henry
Halfbacks: Fritz Pollard, Tom Harmon
Fullback: Ernie Nevers
Quarterback: Sid Luckman
Robeson took liberty with his line by selected "guards" Sonnenberg and Nagurski. He left off Red Grange and saying "Now I'm in a pickle- I'd like to put Jim Thorpe on my team but where would I put him!"
![]() |
| Ray Flaherty, Hall of Famer (coach-player) |
![]() |
| Bobbie Cahn, NFL Official, photo from 1935 |
![]() |
| Ad for game between Rock Island vs Milwaukee, published, Nov. 3, 1923 |
![]() |
| Carl Storck, former NFL Executive, 1921-1941 |
![]() |
| 1955 Curly Lambeau All-Time Team |
![]() |
| 1939 George Halas 6 Greatest Players Ever Seen |
![]() |
| 1941 George Halas All-Time Bears Team, published in Chicago Tribune |