Showing posts with label All-Time Team. Show all posts
Showing posts with label All-Time Team. Show all posts

Monday, July 5, 2021

1941 Jimmy Conzelman All-Time Team

 LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films
Jimmy Conzleman

Today PFJ looks back at Jimmy Conzelman's All-Time Team. 

In 1941 the former NFL quarterback and head coach, who was enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1964 selected his own All-Time Team. No big surprises on his squad. 

He selected:

Ends: Guy Chamberlin, Lavvie Dilweg
Tackles: Ed Healey, Cal Hubbard
Center: George Trafton
Guards: Mike Michalske, Hunk Anderson
Backs: Jim Thorpe, Ernie Nevers, Paddy Driscoll, Bronko Nagurski


Wednesday, November 18, 2020

Consensus Early NFL All-Time Team

 By John Turney

Over the past couple of years, Chris Willis of NFL Films and author of several essential books on the early NFL has posted the All-time teams as chosen by many of the All-Time greats such as Don Hutson, Johnny Blood, Sammy Baugh, and others. Willis even has his own team, based on his heavily-researched series of the top players in the pre-WWII era.

For comparison purposes here is a chart of all those teams. We think it is a fair representation of the consensus of those teams and gives readers unfamiliar with that era who the best players of that era were. 

LINEMAN
Top row—Center: Mel Hein, Guards Dan Fortmann and  Mike Michalske
Bottom row—Tackles: Cal Hubbard, Turk Edwards, Joe Stydahar, and Link Lyman
(votes for tackle very close)

ENDS and PASSERS
Top row—Ends: Bill Hewitt and Don Hutson
Bottom row—T QB: Sammy Baugh; Single Wing TB:  Dutch Clark


RUNNERS
Top Row—Fullback Bronko Nagurski; Blocking back Father Lumpkin; Halback Red Grange
Second row—Halfhback George McAfee; Halfback Cliff Battles, HB-FB Clark Hinkle
Bottom— Halfback Steve Van Buen

Steve Van Buren is sort of an anomy because he played mostly after World War II and he got four votes, one more than Grange and Hinkle and the same as McAfee. Like the voting for the tackles, it was too close to call. So you can make up your mind as to who you want in your backfield.

Friday, September 18, 2020

1948 Don Hutson NFL All-Time Team

 LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films

Today, PFJ will take a look at the NFL All-Time Team by the great Don Hutson. In 1948, just three years after retiring from the Packers as a player, Hutson gave the Green Bay Press-Gazette his All-Time Team of players he played against. He included five players from the rival Chicago Bears, and maybe one surprise be naming Giants end Jim Poole. 

Hutson choose:

Ends- Bill Hewitt, Jim Poole

Tackles- Turk Edwards, George Christensen

Guards- Dan Fortmann, Riley Matheson

Center- Bulldog Turner

Quarterback- Sid Luckman

Halfbacks- Cliff Battles, Steve Van Buren

Fullback- Bronko Nagurski

(Source: Green Bay Press-Gazette, Nov. 24, 1948)

Wednesday, September 16, 2020

1944 Johnny Blood NFL All-Time Team

 LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films
Johnny "Blood" McNally, Packers

Today PFJ looks at the NFL All-Time Team from Johnny "Blood" McNally. In 1944 McNally was asked to list his all-time team. He praised Don Hutson, so much that he listed 3 ends on his team. 

One of his biggest surprise was that he selected Father Lumpkin as his blocking back (or quarterback spot). McNally choose:

Ends- Don Hutson, Bill Hewitt, Brick Mueller

Tackles- Cal Hubbard, Pete "Fats" Henry

Guards- Mike Michalske, Dan Fortmann

Center- Mel Hein

Quarterback-Blocking Back- Father Lumpkin

Halfbacks- Dutch Clark (LHB), Sammy Baugh (RHB)

Fullback- Bronko Nagurski

(Source: Marshfield News-Herald, Aug. 4, 1944)


Monday, September 14, 2020

1939 Jim McMillen NFL All-Time Team

 LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films
Jim McMillen, Bears Guard (1924-1928) 
(Color image by John Turney, PFJ)

PFJ continues this week with another All-Time Team. This one was done in 1939 by Jim McMillen, who played 5 seasons at guard for the Chicago Bears from 1924-1928. He started 66 of 69 career games for the Bears, including many games on the Red Grange 1925-1926 famous barnstorming tour. He was selected First Team All-Pro three times by Chicago Tribune (1926-28) and twice each by Collyers Eye Magazine (1924, 1926) and Green Bay Press-Gazette (1925, 1928). Probably could've played longer but went into pro wrestling.

In 1939 McMillen choose his professional football All-Time Team. Mostly teammate heavy, McMillen selected:

Ends- Don Hutson, Gaynell Tinsley

Tackles- Ed Healey, Link Lyman

Guards- Hunk Anderson, Mike Michalske

Center- Mel Hein

Quarterback- Benny Friedman

Halfbacks- Red Grange, Dutch Clark

Fullback- Bronko Nagurski

 McMillen's biggest surprsies was at end, going away from Bears great Bill Hewitt and selecting Tinsley. He said:

"(Hutson and Tinsley) would have been stars in pro football in any era."

He also thought that Red Grang and Bronko Nagurski were "the two greatest of all-time..."

Friday, September 11, 2020

1947 Tuffy Leemans's All-Time Backfield

 LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films
Tuffy Leemans, number 4, ball carrier for Giants vs Packers 
Color image courtesy of John Turney, PFJ

As the NFL kicked off its 101st season last night we take a look back at some of the league's greatest players. Today we have the Giants former Hall of Fame halfback, Tuffy Leemans, listing his all-time backfield. Leemans played 8 years in the NFL with the Giants (1936-1943), he led the NFL in rushing in his rookie year (1936) and helped the Giants win the 1938 NFL Championship. He was selected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1978. For his all-time backfield he choose: 

QB- Sammy Baugh

HB- Dutch Clark

HB- Cliff Battles

FB- Bronko Nagurski

Leemans had high praise for Sammy Baugh, saying: 

"Baugh is the best passer and the best football player of all-time. He's the finest thing that ever happened to pro football." 



Thursday, September 10, 2020

1941 Paul Robeson All-Time Team

 LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films
Paul Robeson

As the NFL's 101st season kicks off tonight PFJ takes another look back at some of the game's greatest players. Last season the NFL celebrated its 100th All-Time Team. PFJ listed several former coaches and players All-Time choices last season and will post a few more to celebrate this season's opening week. 

Today we feature Paul Robeson's All-Time team from 1941. Robeson, a former Rutgers all-american end, played just 2 seasons in the NFL with the 1921 Akron Pros and 1922 Milwaukee Badgers. He retired from pro football to pursue a successful career as a singer and actor. 

As for his All-Time Team he selected the following: 

Ends: Larry Kelley, Brick Muller

Guards: Gus Sonnenberg, Bronko Nagurski

Tackles: Duke Slater, Pete "Fats" Henry

Halfbacks: Fritz Pollard, Tom Harmon 

Fullback: Ernie Nevers

Quarterback: Sid Luckman

Robeson took liberty with his line by selected "guards" Sonnenberg and Nagurski. He left off Red Grange and saying "Now I'm in a pickle- I'd like to put Jim Thorpe on my team but where would I put him!"

Tuesday, December 24, 2019

Ray Flaherty All-Time Team

LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films
Ray Flaherty, Hall of Famer (coach-player)
On Friday the NFL's 100th All-Time Team will wrap up with the selections of the ten quarterbacks. As we prepare to see the final selections, I came across another older All-Time Team article, this one done in 1990 by Ray Flaherty, the former Hall of Fame coach and two-way end.

His choices were very different since he selected a good mix of older and newer players when he choose the team in 1990. Flaherty picked old-timers he played or coached against, like Mel Hein, Don Hutson, Mike Michalske, Cal Hubbard and Clarke Hinkle; while selecting more modern players like Joe Montana, Steve Largent, Ronnie Lott, and Lawrence Taylor.

The other more unique aspect of this all-time team was that Flaherty choose both an offense and a defense- as he choose Hinkle at linebacker and Hubbard at def. tackle. Usually individuals who played or coached during the two-way era picked one team with 11 men. Not Flaherty. He went with 22 men and one punter and one kicker.

Tuesday, September 3, 2019

Sammy Baugh's 1949 NFL All-Time Opponent Team

LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films

While playing the Los Angeles Rams on the west coast to finish out the 1949 NFL season, Redskins quarterback Sammy Baugh gave an interview with Frank Finch of the Los Angeles Times. During this interview Baugh talked about playing his thirteen seasons with the Redskins (35 years old). At the end of the interview Baugh was asked to give his all-time opponent team. After playing near a decade and a half in the NFL Baugh choose:
Ends: Don Hutson, Jim Poole
Tackles: Joe Stydahar, Al Wistert
Guards: Dan Fortmann, Riley Matheson
Center: Bulldog Turner (offense); Mel Hein (defense)
Single-Wing BB—Larry Craig
T-Formation QB—Sid Luckman
LHB—Steve Van Buren
RHB—Charley Trippi
FB—Bronko Nagurski



Baugh selected Trippi over two more Hall of Famers, Bill Dudley and George McAfee. "How I'd like to throw to Trippi," said Baugh. Slinging Sammy also thought very highly of Riley Matheson, "the best middle linebacker I ever hope to see," mentioned Baugh. Also in the article, Baugh selected two players who he thought were the top defensive players he played against, choosing Hank Soar (New York Giants) and Dudley.

Three years later Baugh retired from the NFL.

Monday, August 26, 2019

Milt Gantenbein 1966 NFL & Packers All-Time Team

LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films

Milt Gantenbein played 10 years (1931-1940) with the Green Bay Packers and ranked #24 on PFJ Pre-WWII Ends list. He was a member of 3 Packers NFL Championship teams (1931, 1936, 1939) and was inducted into the Packers Hall of Fame in 1972. In 1966 (LaCrosse Tribune) he selected two all-time teams- his all-opponent team and an all-time Packers squad.

For his all-opponent team he selected: Bill Hewitt and Gaynell Tinsley at ends; "Wee" Willie Wilkin and "Bruiser" Kinard at tackles; Don  Fortmann and Ox Emerson at guards; Mel Hein at center; Sammy Baugh at quarterback; Byron "Whizzer" White and George McAfee at halfbacks; and Bronko Nagurski at fullback. This squad consisted of seven Hall of Famers and Emerson who should be in. Tinsley and White are not in the HOF but were members of the 1940s NFL All-Decade Team.


As for his all-time Packers team, he selected most of the usual suspects although he selected Bob Monnett over Verne Lewellen. Lavvie Dilweg and Don Hutson at ends; Cal Hubbard and Ernie Smith at tackles; Mike Michalske and Tiny Engebretson at guards; Nate Barager at center; Arnie Herber at quarterback; Johnny Blood and Bobby Monnett at halfback and Clarke Hinkle at fullback.

Monday, August 12, 2019

Bobbie Cahn 1943 All-Time NFL Team

LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films
Bobbie Cahn, NFL Official, photo from 1935

For over two decades the diminutive Bobbie Cahn (who stood about 5-feet tall) was an official (mainly a Referee) in the NFL. He officiated tons of games including the NFL's first post-season game played indoors against the Portsmouth Spartans-Chicago Bears in 1932, as well as the first couple of NFL Championship Games. Cahn was such a character in the early days of the NFL that sometimes he would get his name featured in the ads for games he was working. Here's an example of one that was featured in the Moline Dispatch in 1923 advertising the Rock Island Independents game agains the Milwaukee Badgers in Rock Island.
Ad for game between Rock Island vs Milwaukee, published, Nov. 3, 1923
In 1943 Cahn announced his retirement from the NFL. In turn he selected an All-Time NFL Team and the greatest game he ever worked- the 1934 NFL Championship Game between the Bears and Giants- mostly known as the "Sneakers Game." "That was the most exicting game I ever worked. What a licking the Bears gave the Giants in the first half and how helpless they were in the final half when the Giants came on the field and played in tennis shoes," said Cahn to the United Press after his retirement.

In selecting his All-Time NFL Team, Cahn had some of the normal names of the stars of the 1920's and 1930's. But in naming his No. 1 player he went with a lineman- George Trafton. "Trafton had everything, including a lot of lip for the officials," Cahn commented. "He could diagnose a play quicker than any man who ever played football, and he knew what to do about it."

Here is Cahn's All-Time Team:
Ends- Bill Hewitt, Don Hutson
Tackles- Link Lyman, Ed Healey
Guards- Dan Fortmann, Duke Osborn
Center- George Trafton
Quarterback - Dutch Clark
Halfbacks- Cliff Battles, Clarke Hinkle
Fullback - Bronko Nagurski

Cahn's choices included Osborn over Mike Michalske and selecting fullback Hinkle over all the other halfbacks who played in the first two decades. "Most observers have a hard time deciding whether they should put Nagurski or Hinkle at fullback," said Cahn. "But not me. I always wanted to see Hinkle play halfback. I think he could have been the greatest of all-time. Of course, I only saw Jim Thorpe in his declining years."


In naming his team Cahn also mentions coaches, George Halas, Jimmy Conzelman, and Potsy Clark who gave him some grief while making penalties. "But in all my years in the league I never found a coach who held any malice after a game," said Cahn.

Wednesday, August 7, 2019

Carl Storck's 1939 Greatest Players of All-Time

LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films
Carl Storck, former NFL Executive, 1921-1941
In 1939 Carl Storck named his 11 greatest NFL players of all-time. Storck was the former manager of the Dayton Triangles- a charter franchise of the American Professional Football Association (the forerunner of the NFL). He served as the NFL's secretary-treasurer from 1921-1939, then after the death of Joe F. Carr became NFL President from 1939-1941. So Storck had seen tons of early NFL players to name a qualified list. No big surprises as he named:
Tackle- Turk Edwards
Tackle- Cal Hubbard
Center- Mel Hein
QB- Sammy Baugh
HB- Jim Thorpe
HB- Red Grange
HB- Dutch Clark
HB - Cliff Battles
FB- Clarke Hinkle
FB- Bronko Nagurski
FB- Ernie Nevers


Thursday, August 1, 2019

Curly Lambeau's 1955 All-Time Team

LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis, NFL Films

In 1955 Curly Lambeau selected an All-Time Team. The future Hall of Fame coach had just recently concluded a 33-year NFL coaching career (Packers, 1919-1949, Cardinals, 1950-1951, Redskins, 1952-1953) in which he won 229 games and 6 NFL Championships. His all-time squad had a blend of older and newer players at the time.

His ends were Don Hutson and Tom Fears or Elroy Hirsch; tackles were Link Lyman and Joe Stydahar; guards were Dan Fortmann and Mike Michalske; center was Mel Hein. His backfield consisted of halfbacks George McAfee and Hugh McElhenny; fullback Clarke Hinkle and quarterback Bob Waterfield.
1955 Curly Lambeau All-Time Team

Tuesday, July 30, 2019

George Halas Picks Bears All-Time Team & Greatest Players

LOOKING BACK
By Chris Willis
As the NFL's 100th season approaches PFJ will take a look at several players-coaches testimonies of who they thought were the greatest of all-time. These random posts will show how some of the NFL's greatest players, coaches, executives, and game officials thought about who played the game in the league's early years.

First up is Mr. Papa Bear himself-—George Halas.

In 1939 Halas selected his 6 greatest players he had ever seen. It was a Mount Rushmore of the early stars of the NFL. Bronko Nagurski, Jim Thorpe, Red Grange, Ernie Nevers, Dutch Clark, and Paddy Driscoll.
1939 George Halas 6 Greatest Players Ever Seen
Two years later (1941) Halas choose an All-Time Bears squad that was published in the Chicago Tribune. This team did not include any of the current Bears stars on the 1941 team—so sorry no Sid Luckman, Dan Fortmann or Bulldog Turner. Halas's starting eleven included 7 future Hall of Famers, very impressive for a Bears franchise that was just 21 years old.

The Ends were Bill Hewitt and Bill Karr; tackles were Ed Healey and Link Lyman; guards were Hunk Anderson and Jim McMillen; the center was George Trafton. In the backfield was quarterback Paddy Driscoll, left halfback Red Grange and fullback Bronko Nagurski. Can't argue with those choices.

The only real surprise was Joe Lintzenich at right halfback. Lintzenich only played 2 years with the Bears (1930-31) and scored just 2 career TDs. Halas could've picked Beattie Feathers, Jack Manders or Bill Senn, but went with Lintzenich.


1941 George Halas All-Time Bears Team, published in Chicago Tribune
 In the Tribune article, Halas does have a list of Honorable Mention players.

Wednesday, July 24, 2019

A Team of Oxen, Equally Yoked

LOOKING AHEAD
By John Turney
Some time ago the Pro Football Researchers Association released profiles of a handful of players they thought were Hall of Fame-worthy.

Two of them were linemen—Grover "Ox" Emerson and Al "Big Ox" Wistert. Both Emerson and Wistert were All-Decade selections (both First-team), both were on NFL Championship teams, both were six-time First-team All-Pros, both were on teams that set statistical marks, some of which still stand to this day in team or NFL annals and yet neither were in the Hall of Fame which was the purpose of those dossiers—to inform Hall of Fame voters of a pair of NFL greats who fell through the nomination cracks.

Not only were the "Ox-men" on the First-team Hall of Fame All-Decade Teams for their respective decades, but they were also consensus choices for the "Combined" All-1930s and 1940s teams.


The "Ox" who played with the Lions, Emerson, in a recent profile by Chris Willis a producer at NFL Films and author of many books from the relevant eras, had many excellent "testimonials" or "What they said" quotes about him.

Here are a few:
“I regard Emerson one of the greatest linemen I have ever seen perform on a football field. Having him out of our first five games hurt us more than anyone will ever know.”—Potsy Clark, former Spartans-Lions head coach, in 1935.

“(Ox) Emerson, the Detroit guard, according to Link Lyman of our Bears, is the fastest, ‘slicing’ forward and the hardest to block, he has ever met in football. And Link is almost a football line all by himself.”—Red Grange, former Bears Hall of Fame back, wrote in 1934.

“Emerson’s low charging made him one of the toughest guards to drive out of play, while he was fast enough to pull out and block on the Lions’ intricate reverse plays.”—wrote the UPI on Emerson when naming him to 1936 NFL All-Pro team.

Willis also mentioned that as he was a major part of the 1935 NFL Champion Lions, and that the "1936 the Lions set an NFL record for rushing yards in a season with 2,885 yards (in 12 games), a record that stood until 1972 when the Miami Dolphins broke it (in a 14-game season)"

Here are the team records as found in the Lions media guide. Three of the top five seasons for attempts are still listed. With a team that featured Barry Sanders on it, two of the top three rushing seasons are still part of the Emerson/Dutch Clark-era. Pretty impressive.
Emerson, as a two-way player (as almost all were in that era) was also part of the Lions 1934 Defense that posted seven shutouts and allowed just 59 points on the season.

Clearly, the defensive charts are more misleading due to era, season length and so on. But the 1950s and 1960s Lions teams were known for defense...and the 1930s defense still was dominant. A deep look would be required to get more meaning, but it is fair to say it was a great defense and Ox Emerson was a part of that.

As far as NFL records, the Lions from that era are still in the NFL Record and Fact Book's pages.

They still hold the record for most yards rushing in a game and are second in consecutive seasons leading the NFL in rushing yards behind a pair of Bears teams—one was recent, even.


And there are still third in fewest points allowed.

******************************************

Wistert's "testimonials" include George Allen in his book Pro Football’s 100 Greatest Players and also selected him as one of the ten best defensive linemen of all time. Allen wrote, “He was as fine a blocker as you could want. He didn’t have the size to overpower people on the pass block, but he was a master of every kind of block.”

In 2016 the Talk of Fame Network had this quote as well, "Al was the greatest offensive tackle I’ve seen or played with," said former teammate Bosh Pritchard. He also said, "He was our best offensive tackle," referring to the great Eagles teams of the late 1940s.

Steve Van Buren set the NFL's career rushing mark in 1949 (which he held for six seasons) Wistert was the most decorated blocker the Eagles had. And during the "Wistert era" the Eagles were at the top or near the top in rushing offense, and scoring offense and were at or near the top of total defense and scoring defense as well, topping it off with two NFL Championships.

Wistert was a "quick type" tackle in our view He would cut block a lot—but that was common for the era. He was a good athlete for a tackle, not a big, slow "power type" as was often seen in that era. 

As a defender, Allen added, "He always played in perfect position and was seldom off his feet. He was a superb pursuit man and seemed somehow to get in on every play. He was a sure tackler. He was maybe best against the run, but he was among the good early pass rushers."

As a pass rusher, he used his hands pretty well, which was unusual for that era when players would often lead with their shoulders. He was no Gino Marchetti (who advanced the use of hands in pass rushing in the 1950s), mind you, but he was very good at getting pressure. He was also excellent in pursuit in run defense.

In the mid-1940s sometimes he played what looks to be a standup defensive tackle/linebacker position - a hybrid position. From it, he'd take a motioning T-running back out of the backfield in man-to-man coverage. It was a wrinkle in how the Eagles coaches would coverages in the mid-1940s. That is a tough assignment for a defensive tackle.

In that same era he could be seen playing stand-up defensive end as well, which looking at it today would be considered an outside linebacker/edge position and he got good pressure when going after the passer from that spot.

He really does not get enough credit for how good a defender he was. He did a lot of things, played the run from a down position, rushed from an up or down position and covered from an inside stand-up position. 

Van Buren's accolades still dot the Eagles' recent Media Guides



And to this day the 1944 Eagles are second in fewest rushing yards allowed in a season. (Again, we get it's a different era, but the point is to highlight what the offenses and defenses of the "Ox" men did and that they hold up, not to prove said offenses and defenses played under the same rules and circumstances, we know they didn't).
Here are the teams that allowed the fewest rushing yards from 1937-52. Four Eagles teams, in which Wistert was a starter (five if you count the Steagles of 1943 where he was a rookie).
And there are more things we could clip and post to further buttress the accomplishments of Emerson and Wistert.

But the bottom line is this:
We feel confident there are plenty of players in recent eras and from eras gone by that don't check as many boxes as these two do.

Two oxen make a team and for them to work well they have to be yoked together, equally, or there will be an imbalance and the team will not be efficient. These two are so even it is impossible to separate them. Maybe it's time, with the expanded Centennial Class of 2020, to use two of those "Centennial" slots on these oxen. It would be fitting, fair, and just.