| Crazy Legs Hirsh |
| 1937 Title Game |
| Crazy Legs Hirsh |
| 1937 Title Game |
By Eric Goska
Woeful special teams. Lapses in defense. Double-digit deficits.
For two quarters, the Bears had the Packers reeling. But Chicago
picked the wrong time and the wrong place to stage an upset.
Aaron Rodgers, Green Bay’s starting quarterback these past
14 years, is nearly invincible at home in December. He again provided evidence
of that Sunday night as his Packers downed the Bears 45-30 to improve to 10-3
and remain in the race for the NFC’s top seed in the playoffs.
Here’s a question for you Green and Gold fans: Anything in
the first half spark concern?
Maybe: a.) two first-quarter sacks by Chicago’s Robert Quinn;
b.) Malik Taylor’s botched attempt to field a kickoff that gave the Packers the
ball at the five instead of the 40 had he let it roll out of bounds; or c.) Mason
Crosby’s out-of-bounds kickoff that afforded a short field on which the Bears
scored in three plays?
Anything in the first half trigger panic?
Perhaps: a.) Jakeem Grant’s 46-yard touchdown reception; b.)
Damiere Byrd’s 54-yard touchdown reception; or c.) Grant’s 97-yard, a franchise-record punt return for a score?
How about all of the above? Each of those plays, in one way
or another, helped Chicago go up 10-0 and 24-14.
In particular, the long gains stand out. All three came in
the second quarter in which the Bears exploded for 24 points.
In ringing the bell from long distance, perhaps the Bears
were on to something. Only twice previously in more than 100 years of
regular-season football had Green Bay given up three touchdowns of 40 or more
yards in a single quarter. And both times – against the Rams in 1945 (20-7) and
Lions in 1951 (52-35) – the Packers lost.
Up 27-21 at the break, the Bears and their coach Matt Nagy were
feeling good.
“Matt Nagy was so excited and thrilled for his team when I
caught up with him at halftime,” said NBC sideline reporter Kathryn Tappen. “He
said, ‘I’m having so much fun.’”
Was Nagy not aware of Rodger’s record at Lambeau Field in December?
With an entire half to play, the record-setting quarterback had plenty of time
to improve upon an already impressive track record.
Stathead Football claims to be “the most powerful research
tool in sports.” Whether true or not, the site is more than capable of producing
interesting finds.
A search for passers who attempted at least 100 tosses in
regular-season games at home in December from 1950 to 2021 yields 281 names. Those
on the list range from Don Trull or Stan Gelbaugh to Hall of Famers such as Johnny
Unitas or Joe Montana.
Players can be ranked by quantity – attempts, completions,
yards passing and more – or quality – passer rating and winning percentage.
Rodgers, no surprise, is No. 1 in passer rating with a mark
of 114.4. Lamar Jackson (111.3) and Dak Prescott (109.5) are the only others
above 103, and both attempted far fewer passes than Rodgers.
In beating the Bears by 15, Rodgers improved to 23-3 (.885) at
home in December. Of those who played in at least 12 such December games, only Trent
Green (15-1; .938) and Daryle Lamonica (13-1; .929) have a higher winning
percentage than Rodgers.
Six of Rodgers’ 23 wins came against two teams: the Lions
(3) and Bears (3).
In deconstructing Chicago, Rodgers completed 29 of 37 passes
for 341 yards and four touchdowns. His passer rating (141.1) was nearly double
that of his counterpart, Justin Fields (70.8).
Rodgers matched his December home high with 19 first downs
passing. Seventeen came on scoring drives.
Rodgers completed 10 in a row, from late in the second
quarter until deep into the third. Those 10 passes produced 162 yards and two
touchdowns – a 38-yarder to Davante Adams and a 23-yarder to Aaron Jones.
His team up 38-27 heading into the fourth, Rodgers didn’t flinch.
He completed six straight for 39 yards and a touchdown as the Packers took
eight minutes, 38 seconds off the clock to go up 45-27 with 4:33 left.
For Rodgers, this was his sixth 300-yard performance in
December at Lambeau. It was the 16th time he compiled a rating of 100 or better.
Numbers aside, Rodgers just wasn’t going to allow Chicago
beat him on his home turf. Not in December, anyway.
It’s a stance that can’t hurt when Green Bay hosts Cleveland
on Christmas Day.
| Ray Brown |
![]() |
| Gaynell Tinsley |
![]() |
| Bill George |
![]() |
| Andy Dalton |
By Eric Goska
![]() |
| From the Green Bay Press-Gazette, April 29, 1955 |
Max McGee is the Packers’ all-time leader in net punting
average. So says The Football Database.
What say I? Poppycock! Malarkey! Totally false!
Statisticians are like offensive lineman. We tend to get
noticed only when mistakes are made.
And the error being perpetuated by The Football Database begs for correction.
Bear with me. A little background information is in order.
The NFL began tracking net punting average in
1976. Take the yards a player punted, subtract the yards those punts were
returned and then take away an additional 20 yards for every touchback the
punter had.
Presto! You have a player’s net punting average.
Of course, we figure freaks are only too happy to take any
metric, regardless of when it was created, and apply it to players who played
before it existed. We want to know how the old-timers measure up.
And in that spirit, The Football Database ranks the top seven punters in Packers history by net punting average (minimum 250 punts). I’ve
recreated their list for easier viewing.
Notice the zeros in the columns labeled TB and In20 for McGee
and Donny Anderson. They are there because no information was kept on
touchbacks and punts inside the 20 prior to 1976.
To its credit, The Football Database admits: “Net Average statistics are only
available for 1976-2021 seasons. Yet two paragraphs earlier it proclaims: “Max
McGee is the Green Bay Packers career leader in net punting average with 41.3.”
Pick up a copy of my book, “Green Bay Packers: A Measure of
Greatness” published in 2004. It lists, season by season, the net punting
average for every Packers player from 1954 through 1975. Furthermore, on page
339, I list the career net punting average for every Packers punter from 1954
onward.
Now, it took years to unearth every touchback. It took time to
separate out which return yardage belonged to which player.
But I dived in knowing that I could provide a more complete
picture than what was available. Maybe someone might pay attention. Maybe somebody
might notice.
Guess not.
Here, then, is an accurate list of the top punters in Packers history based on net punting average. Sorry, Max, but you’re not No. 1.
![]() |
| Credit: CBS |
![]() |
| Garland Grange, Chicago Bears, circa 1930 |
Most football fans know the name of Red Grange. But do they know that he had a younger brother, who not only played football, but followed his older brother playing at Wheaton High School, University of Illinois and in the NFL with the Chicago Bears.
Today we look back at the career of Garland Grange who celebrates a birthday today.
Garland
Arthur Grange was born on December 2, 1906, in Forksville, Pennsylvania just
like Red.
The family saw tragedy when Sadie Grange, the mother of Red/Garland passed away at the young age of 31. Lyle Grange then moved his family to Wheaton, Illinois to be closer to his siblings.
Growing up Garland quickly sported flaming red hair, like his father, but not quite like his brother. Red’s hair was more auburn tint than flaming red. Just like Red, Garland picked up a few nicknames, going by “Gardy” and “Pinkey.”
![]() |
| In cowboy outfits, Red Grange (left) and Garland, circa 1914. |
He would idolize his brother growing up. Because their father worked long hours as the police chief in town, the two siblings looked after each other. While Red was completing his freshmen year things were going fine at the Grange apartment on Front Street. Although their father was on-call twenty-four hours a day the two Grange boys looked after each other. “I did all the cooking at home and, if I have to say so myself, was a darn good cook. My brother Garland did the shopping and we took turns washing and wiping the dishes. We also did the house cleaning ourselves since Dad was generally too busy to help with any of the chores,” wrote Red in his autobiography.
Wheaton High School, Garland graduated in 1924. In the high school yearbook Gardie was quoted as saying, “three things shine- the sun, the moon, my hair.”
As his brother became the most famous football player in the country (circa 1924-1925) Garland followed in his brother’s footsteps. He played end, not halfback, at Wheaton High then continued his gridiron career at the University of Illinois under head coach Bob Zuppke. As a freshman (Red was a Junior in 1924) Garland suffered a bad shoulder injury that kept him out of practice. The following fall (1925) Garland was going to play with his brother for the first time. But his shoulder injury re-occurred during fall practice. He would have surgery on it, keeping him out of, not just the 1925 season but 1926 too.
![]() |
| Garland Grange, Univ. of Illinois, circa 1927 |
Despite the health issues Garland tried to stay in shape, even helping his brother on his famous ice route in their hometown of Wheaton. A job that keep the siblings together all the time. A recipe for disaster. Red spent more time with his brother during this summer than he had ever done before. Garland had just graduated from high school and would work the ice route with him to prepare for his freshmen year at Illinois. The two made the job fun, acting like typical siblings. In a 1978 interview Red remembers clowning around with his kid brother:
“We use to have some of the greatest arguments, Gardy and I when working on the ice truck. We’re out in the country and I remember this so well, we stopped the truck and turned it off and got out into a field. We had the doggonesdest fight you ever saw. We both are bloody. We clean up, and get back in the truck and go to work. We work all day together the both of us.”
![]() |
| On ice truck in Wheaton, IL, Red (left) and Garland, circa 1925 |
Over one summer they did find time to work on their football skills. Zuppke had given Red a few footballs to take home so he could work on his throwing skills. He wanted Red to be more of a threat to pass so the opposition wouldn’t be sure of him when he got the ball. “I started out by winging baseballs to my brother Garland for hours at a time until I developed near-perfect control and the ability to throw on the run. Then I switched to throwing a football. It got so I could pass with a high degree of accuracy at twenty or thirty yards,” recalled Red.
In the fall of 1927 Garland was back at Illinois. He was finally healthy enough to play football, his shoulder now completely healed. He would play his senior year for Zuppke. Peaking physically, Garland now stood at six-foot tall and weighed 173-pounds. Red would be very proud of his younger brother, always instilling confidence and building up his self-esteem. It wasn’t easy being the brother of “Red Grange.” “I don’t see why he shouldn’t be a great football player. He has a swell build, he can run the hundred in 10.1, and he has the finest hands you’d want to see. I know just how big he is, for he wears all my clothes,” laughed Red to the press that fall. “And if anybody ever had intestinal strength Pinkey has. When were kids he used to tackle guys in the neighborhood that I didn’t care to run into. That was when we played on a corner lot across the street. Garland’s hands are his great asset and he can pass mighty accurately. His hands are about the biggest I have ever seen, much bigger than mine. The baseball managers that cry for men with big hands should see Garland’s claws.”
Wearing jersey number twenty-two Garland helped the Illini to a perfect season, 7-0, and the Big Ten Championship. At this time Garland didn’t know if he was going to play pro football. Soon that changed. After suffering a horrible knee injury Red sat out the 1928 football season, but in 1929 he was recruited back on the field by George Halas to play for his Chicago Bears. Red brought along his younger brother. For three years the two Grange brothers played for the Bears (1929-1931).
![]() |
| Garland Grange in front of older brother Red, Chicago Bears, circa 1930 |
Playing
mostly at end for the Bears, Garland became a reliable, albeit not spectacular,
player.
On October 27th, the two brothers would make family history. In a game against the Minneapolis Red Jackets at Wrigley Field, Red tossed a 16-yard touchdown pass to Garland as the Bears clinched an easy 27-0 victory. It would be the only time they would connect on a scoring pass in their NFL careers. Red once talked about his brother’s personality on the field:
“My brother was an entirely different type of personality on the football field than I. While I was a quiet sort of player who could feel it inside, he could stimulate the entire team with his enthusiasm. He breathed fire and brimstone, and before a game we almost wanted to tie him up for fear he might go out on the field and kill somebody.”
The two brothers seemed to be polar opposites on the field, but best friends off of it.
![]() |
| Garland (left) wears his brother's famous fur coat during 1925-1926 barnstorming tour |
In 1931, their last year playing together, the Bears traveled east to play the Giants at the Polo Grounds (Nov. 15th). The attraction of Red and All-Pro fullback Bronko Nagurski brought out a crowd of 20,000, that included New York Mayor Jimmy Walker and former New York Governor Alfred Smith who saw an exciting game with a Grange making the key play of the contest. After trading touchdowns with missed extra points the two teams were tied 6-6 late in the fourth quarter. After a huge interception by the Bears, the clock showed less than one minute to play. The Bears then called a pass play. Carl Brumbaugh fired a short strike to Garland Grange who did the rest sprinting twenty-eight yards for the game winning score. One newspaper headlines wrote: “Red’s Kid Brother Steals Show”
Playing in the shadow of Red was never easy, Garland always took it in stride. In 1932 he left the Chicago Bears to play for the St. Louis Veterans, a non-NFL team, as player-coach. The younger Grange installed the T-Formation and played right end. He would guide the Veterans to a 2-2-1 record. He then would finish the season playing a few games for the Memphis Tigers, another non-NFL team.
Garland would then retire from football. As Red would stay close to the game as a player, coach and broadcaster, Garland would enjoy the game mostly from the sidelines. He would move away from the cold winds of Chicago moving to Miami. He would then get married (Virginia), work in the credit department at Richards Department Store, and roam the sidelines as a game official for many Miami high school football games.
![]() |
| Red with Garland, sitting at desk at Richards Department Store, Miami, circa 1958 |
On May 28, 1981 in Miami Garland passed away from a heart attack at the age of 74.
In 1937 Bob Zuppke compared the two Grange brothers, saying “Red was exceptionally fast, but he wasn’t quite as speedy on the straightway as his brother, Garland. Gardie didn’t have Red’s elusiveness- no player has ever had it- nor did he have Red’s pickup. He had more dash and fire. Red was a soundless rocket.”
So, on his birthday, we remember Garland Grange.
![]() |
| Garland Grange, Chicago Bears, circa 1930 |