Saturday, January 28, 2017

Hall of Fame Predictions: The Running Backs

LOOKING AHEAD
By John Turney

The day before Super Bowl 51 the Hall of Fame selection committee will meet and debate and discuss the credentials of 15 modern-era players, one senior and two contributors. We will attempt to break down and predict who will be in the Class of 2017.

Remember only five of the 15 modern-era players can be voted in, and there will be a simple yes or no vote on the contributors (Paul Tagliabue and Jerry Jones) and the senior nominee (Ken Easley).

Now, the runners:

The Hype:  LaDainian Tomlinson was a consensus 2006 NFL  MVP, the 2006 NFL Walter Payton Man of the Year and on the Pro Football Hall of Fame First-team All-2000s Team. he was also a four-time First-team All-Pro and was a Second-team All-Pro twice more. he was voted to five Pro Bowls. he led the NFL in rushing twice and in rushing touchdowns three times.  Additionally he's considered one of the best, if not the best, receiving back of his era.

The Knock:  Again, no real knocks, other than lack of a Super Bowl ring, but that has not hindered candidates these days like it did in the 1980s and 1990s when such players were held out (just name any Minnesota Viking).

The Prediction:  We think Tomlinson will be a First-ballot Hall of Famer.
The Hype:  Terrell Davis has almost all the Tomlinson has, an MVP, plus a rushing title, two rushing TD titles, was a 2-time Offensive Player of the Year, plus a Super Bowl MVP and two Super Bowl Rings. He was a 3-time All-Pro and a 3-time Pro Bowler.

The Knock:  What he lacks in longevity. He suffered the severe knee injury and never really recovered.

The Prediction:  This one is tough. But, we are going out on a limb. Davis made the Final 10 last year and we think he will move up to the Final 5 and be elected. With Ken Easley in the mix, voters can see that Davis had plenty of "extras", that is to say, he wasn't just All-Pro, he was a Player of the Year and MVP and a Super Bowl MVP. We think the "Gale Sayers exception" will apply and that is the fact a player does not have longevity can be ignored if that player was truly great and the longevity was cut short due to a career-ending injury. So, we predict this year for Davis.

Hall of Fame Predictions: The Cornerback

LOOKING AHEAD
By John Turney
The day before Super Bowl 51 the Hall of Fame selection committee will meet and debate and discuss the credentials of 15 modern-era players, one senior and two contributors. We will attempt to break down and predict who will be in the Class of 2017.

Remember only five of the 15 modern-era players can be voted in, and there will be a simple yes or no vote on the contributors (Paul Tagliabue and Jerry Jones) and the senior nominee (Ken Easley).

Now, the coverage man:
The Hype: Pro Football Hall of Fame Second-team All-2000s Team, and a two-time First-team All-pro and a 5-time Pro Bowler. He led the NFL in interceptions twice. He also was terrific in the playoffs and has 3 Super Bowl rings, though he was hurt for most of 2004. Among the metrics of the day, Law usually was among the leaders in lowest passer rating against, a stat that attempts to individualize passing stats that a cornerback allows.

The Knock: It could be said he was not All-Pro all that often (twice), and 5 Pro Bowls is somewhat less than, say, Aeneas Williams, so on the "honors" scale he may be a bit below other inducted corners.

The Prediction:  Law will likely get eliminated in to vote to the Final 10. He's new to the Final 15 and perhaps lesser known among some. Even though he had a great career, he's still a "sleeper" if you will. We think he will eventually get in, just not this year.

Hall of Fame Predictions: The Edge Rusher

LOOKING AHEAD
By John Turney

The day before Super Bowl 51 the Hall of Fame selection committee will meet and debate and discuss the credentials of 15 modern-era players, one senior and two contributors. We will attempt to break down and predict who will be in the Class of 2017.

Remember only five of the 15 modern-era players can be voted in, and there will be a simple yes or no vote on the contributors (Paul Tagliabue and Jerry Jones) and the senior nominee (Ken Easley).

Now, the edge rusher:

The Hype: Jason Taylor was the 2006 NFL AP Defensive Player of the Year and 2007 NFL Walter Payton Man of the Year a 2-time AFC Defensive Player of the Year, and was a Second-team All-Decade selection. In addition, he was a three-time First-team All-Pro and a six-time Pro Bowler. He had 9 defensive touchdowns and three safeties for a total of 12 defensive scores. He had 139.5 sacks, 69.5 run/pass stuffs, and 46 forced fumbles and recovered 29. As far as the "numbers" go, he ranks near the top of this year's finalists.

The Knock:  No real knocks on Taylor's career unless someone wants to make an issue of his lack of a Super Bowl ring.

The Prediction:  Taylor will eventually be elected to the Hall of Fame in our view, but not this year. We think he will advance to the Final 10, but be eliminated there. We equate his career, roughly, with others of his era, like Michael Strahan and he was not a first-ballot HOFer.

Friday, January 27, 2017

Hall of Fame Predictions: The Kicker

LOOKING AHEAD
By John Turney
The day before Super Bowl 51 the Hall of Fame selection committee will meet and debate and discuss the credentials of 15 modern-era players, one senior and two contributors. We will attempt to break down and predict who will be in the Class of 2017.

Remember only five of the 15 modern-era players can be voted in, and there will be a simple yes or no vote on the contributors (Paul Tagliabue and Jerry Jones) and the senior nominee (Ken Easley).

Now, the kicker:

The Hype:  Morten Andersen was a Five-time First-team All-Pro, once a Second-team All-Pro and was a 7-time Pro Bowler. He is the NFL's all-time leading scorer, kicked the most field goals all time, is a 2-time First-team All-Decade selection.

He was, also, the one of the first couple of kickers to be reliable from 50-yards and out and not just from 50- or 51-yards, but from 54- and 55 yards. He was a definate advantage for the Saints and Falcons, before the rest of the NFL's kickers caught up. Also, with his big leg, he was an aide to the kickoff coverage teams, being able to outpace most other kickers in touchbacks.

The Knock: Really only that he had a bit of an advantage kicking indoors in 22 of his 25 seasons. Also, there are so many good and worthy players, for good or bad, kickers get overlooked.

The Prediction:  We think Andersen will make the Top 10 this year and has a chance for induction, but will have to wait. We don't see him making the Top 5 and then getting the 80% yes votes needed.

As with most, if not all, of the Final 15, he's worthy of induction, he was a cut (or two) above even the good kickers of his day.

Hall of Fame Predictions: The Quarterback

LOOKING AHEAD
By John Turney
The day before Super Bowl 51 the Hall of Fame selection committee will meet and debate and discuss the credentials of 15 modern-era players, one senior and two contributors. We will attempt to break down and predict who will be in the Class of 2017.

Remember only five of the 15 modern-era players can be voted in, and there will be a simple yes or no vote on the contributors (Paul Tagliabue and Jerry Jones) and the senior nominee (Ken Easley).

Now, the quarterback:

The Hype:  Kurt Warner is a 2-time MVP (actually a 3-time MVP as he won the final NEA MVP in 2008 to go with his 1999 AP and PFWA and 2001 AP awards) and a Super Bowl MVP. He set plenty of records in his time in the NFL and led his team to three Super Bowls. In those games he played well and had his team in position to win, but lost two in the final seconds.  He is a two-time passing champion and led the NFL in TD passes twice and his 7.9 yards per attempt is 6th all time. He was also the 2008 Walter Payton NFL Man of the Year.

The Knock:  The knock is the so-called "donut hole" in his career, the few years he spent injured and in the doldrums in-between his Super Bowl appearances.

The Prediction:  The donut hole caused Warner to not really be worthy of first-ballot consideration but now, a couple years later and with Brett Favre out of the way, we predict Warner will be elected and then inducted in the Summer of 2017.

Hall of Fame Predictions: The Safeties

LOOKING AHEAD
By John Turney

The day before Super Bowl 51 the Hall of Fame selection committee will meet and debate and discuss the credentials of 15 modern-era players, one senior and two contributors. We will attempt to break down and predict who will be in the Class of 2017.

Remember only five of the 15 modern-era players can be voted in, and there will be a simple yes or no vote on the contributors (Paul Tagliabue and Jerry Jones) and the senior nominee (Ken Easley).

We start today with the safeties.


The Hype:  Easley was an NFL Defensive Player of the Year in 1984 and an AFC Defensive Player of the Year in 1983 and 1984. He was a four-time First-team All-Pro and a Second-team All-Pro once and was voted to five Pro Bowls and was a Second-team All-AFC in 1986. So, six of his seven seasons he garnered post-season honors, along with being All-Rookie in 1981. He also was an All-Decade selection.

He was what could be considered a prototype strong safety in that he could cover, hit, and support the run defense. He had height (6-3) and was fast for a strong safety.

The Knock: He had to retire early due to injuries and a medical concern, so longevity is not one of the things that he has on his "resume" if you will.

The Prediction:  We think he will receive 80% yes votes and be elected to the Class of 2017.

The Hype: Dawkins, like Easley, was a prototype safety, but a free safety. He could do it all. He was a five-time First-team All-Pro and was voted to nine Pro Bowls.

He picked off 37 passes, had 26 sacks and 47.5 run and pass stuffs, showing he spent time "in the box" as well as in coverage. He spent his final three seasons in Denver as a strong safety and did very well there in two of those three seasons.

The Knock:  The only negative to his being elected is that he is up for the first time and voters will have to consider if his career has the certain cachet needed to be a First-ballot player.

The Prediction:  We predict Dawkins will bump John Lynch back in the que but not be elected tis year. We predict enough voters will think he doesn't have the little "extra" needed to be in the Ronnie Lott/Larry Wilson class of safeties.

The Hype:  Lynch was a nine-time Pro Bowler and was part of the best coverage defense during his time in Tampa Bay. Though a strong safety there, with the Tampa-2 system, Lynch spent lots of time in coverage, taking 1/2 of the deep zone, something some strong safeties were not asked to do.

He had 44 run/pass stuffs and was usually one of the Buccaneers leading tacklers, totaling over 1000 career tackles and he was part of a Super Bowl winning team. He was a three-time First-team All-Pro, and was the NFL Alumni Defensive Back of the Year in 2000.

The Knock:  He only had 26 interceptions and no defensive touchdowns. For a safety that played quite a lot of Cover-2, that is a low total for interceptions, though he also did play in the box as well.

The Prediction:  Lynch was in last year's Final 10 but did not make the Final 5. Usually, those in the Final 10 move up and have a real shot at election, the next year, but with Dawkins and Easley in the mix, we think he will not make the Final 10 this year.


Thursday, January 26, 2017

Personnel Groupings: Coryell, Walsh, Earhardt-Perkins


LOOKING BACK
By John Turney

Don Coryell
 
Bill Walsh

Ron Earhardt
These days many, if not most, personnel groupings in NFL offenses have been shortened to numbers or digits, for example, 2 running backs and 1 tight end and 2 wide receivers would be "21". Or if there is one running back and 2 tight ends and 2 wide receivers it would be "12". The number of wide receivers is left off to shorten the terminology.

Back in the day, however, there was terminology for those groupings and different offenses would use different verbiage.

Three of the most-used offenses in the 1980s through the mid-2000s (we contend most offenses are hybrids and borrow from each other the routes, but many still maintain much of the verbiage for formations but it seems most use digits or numbers for the personnel groupings).

Here are examples from those three offenses we think were most prevalent, the Coryell system, the Walsh system (called the West Coast Offense) and the Earhardt-Perkins offense.

First is Coryell, then WCO, then Earhardt-Perkins: