Monday, July 17, 2017

Analysis: Bob McGinn MMQB All-Time Draft Team

By John Turney

Bob McGinn MMQB All-Time Draft Team is next up for review and he, like my team, is a 3-4 defense.

 His safeties fit well as so do his outside backers. His inside backers have played some (Seau anyway) in a 3-4 defense but both would project well. Pat Williams was a 4-3 nose tackle, so the move to 3-4 nose would not be a problem. Reggie White played some in a 3-4, though he thrived more in a 4-3, but he and Selmon would do well with this set of players.

McGinn has two finesse-type left tackles, but moving one to right tackle would be possible with these two. Outside Anthony Munoz I think Walter Jones is the best left tackle. So, I'd project that Pace would have to move sides.
Tommy Davis will handle both kicking and punting. His punting is great, but in my view his kicking was average.

Analysis: Dan Fouts MMQB All-Time Draft Team

By John Turney

There is no doubt Dan Fouts got the pick of the litter in kickers and punters. he took Ray Guy in the first round and a few round later too Jan Stenerud.
 Fouts picked two free safeties but both were great. His corners were excellent, both Hall of Famers. He picked a true middle linebacker, a true strong side linebacker (Wilcox) and a true weakside linebacker (Jackson).  He also picked a left and right defensive end. With Johnson and Kinard it's hard to tell, but Johnson was a rush tackle who was very productive. It actually is a very interesting team. Green and Dean are a bit undersized but they could play. Green was a truly underrated player. Caught in a decade with a lot of good defensive ends.
All of this works except for Bruce Matthews at left tackle. he played some right tackle early in his career but was moved inside. Once, he was moved to left tackle to match up against Bruce Smith. Smith lit Matthews up for 4 sacks and Matthews again moved back inside, where he was dominant. So, I am not a fan of him at tackle, to say the least.
There are no criticisms in the special teams other than where they were drafted. All have a legitimate argument for bing G.O.A.T.s.

Analysis: Gil Brandt MMQB All-Time Draft Team

By John Turney

Gil Brandt's team is up next:

Brandt picked fine safeties that match well. However, Brandt didn't pick a middle linebacker. he has a rushbacker in Thomas (a 3-4 fit) and two fine WILLs in Brooks and Howley. Howley, did, however play some strong side linebacker with the Cowboys, but finding a MIKE in these three will be hard. The tackles are fine, especially since Klecko can play over a center when needed. Brandt picked two right ends, though both were great pass rushers, he would get a lot of sacks from he outside. But which would play on the strong side?
There is no criticism of Brandt's offense. One question could be asked, "I there enough ball for both Payton and Brown?".
Rod Woodson would do the returns for Brandt. His kicker is outstanding, one of the tops already. I am not a fan of Lechler, though. When you look at his stats or watch him punt you can always expect a return. He's not like Hekker or Thomas Morstead who are really trying for net yardage. Lechler reminds me of Rohn Stark or Jerrell Wilson. 

Analysis: Rick Gosselin MMQB All-Time Draft Team

By John Turney

Now it time to look at Rick Gosselin's MMQB All-Time Draft Team.
Gosselin, like myself wanted to field a team that could play at positions they were familiar with. In my own critique, I showed how a failed in a couple of instances. Here, it seems Gosselin did as well. He picked awesome linebackers, but both the outside 'backers were left linebackers. Ham was tremendous at coverage and sometimes get's called a weak side backer, but wasn't. Paul Zimmerman picked Ham as his weakside 'backer for SI's All-Century team and here, Gosselin puts him there as well. It is so pervasive that one time Jack Youngblood told Ham, "Well, you were a right side backer, you didn't have the tight end over you". Ham replied, "No, Jack, Andy (Russell) was on the right, I was on the left." Youngblood persisted and said "No, you were the weakside guy". Ham, again said "No, Jack, I was on the strong side". Youngblood now relates how dumb he felt arguing with the one man who KNEW the exact answer. "I just couldn't get over how a guy that small could be a left linebacker".

Regardless, Ham projects well to the weakside and could do it with ease.

Gosselin also calls Lipscomb his power tackle. But in my viewing of Lipscomb with the Colts he was a sideline to sideline tackle and with the Steelers he was an up-the-field type. In neither place was he taking on a guard and playing like, say a Merlin Olsen or Joe Greene. However, his size would allow him to take on that role and work with one of the two best pass rushing defensive tackles ever in John Randle.

Gosselin also chose two left defensive ends. Jones was a Ram mainstay at left end and Neil Smith was a truly fine left end for the Chiefs. Jones, though could have been a dominant right end as well. Emlen Tunnell was a left safety, what would roughly translate as a strong safety and Easley was a strong safety, but either one of them could have moved to right or free safety since both were superior athletes.
The offense works well and even has a running back who played fullback (Roger Craig) as a lead blocker. Michael Irvin is a true "X" split end and Lance Alworth was a true flanker (Z). Gosselin also nailed the line in their places with true left and right tackles and left and right guards. With his quarterback and these skill players, Gosselin may have won the SI MMQB draft.
The kicker and returner are top-notch. I am not a fan of Jerrell Wilson. But I can see why others love him, he got lots of honors, even was voted the top punter of the AFL. But in doing research he not only had a lot of punts blocked (12) he didn't have a tremendous net punting averages year-in and year-out. He seemed to used his powerful leg to kick beyond the coverage in too many seasons. However, he did have two seasons in which he led AFL in net punting (1964 and 1968) and one (1968) in which he had a 40.3 net. 

Analysis: Ron Wolf MMQB All-Time Draft Team

By John Turney

Next up is Ron Wolf's team:

The safeties match, Dillon a right safety and Robinson a player who played both. He was a left safety early in his career and finished as a free safety. The tackles fit perfectly. Joe Greene was a left tackle, a run stuffer who could rush, Lilly was a right tackle, a slasher who could rush well and could play the run. The ends are both left ends. Jackson a crushing run stuffer and Marchetti a rusher who played the run on the way to the quarterback. One of them could project to the other side, Jackson, in fact, played the right side for a couple of years, but he really licked right-side speed. he fit the left much better. Ted Hendricks is one of the rare players who could play a lot of positions and DID. 

He played ROLB and LOLB in a 3-4 and also played RLB and LLB in a 4-3 scheme, all at top levels. Tippett was a 3-4 outside linebacker and a left defensive end on passing downs. Like with Joel Bussert's team he has to project into a 4-3.
 This is a well-balanced offense with a good blocker at fullback and at tight end. It has a great Qb and deep speed at wide receiver and the line works. Well done.
Baugh is a fine pick but I am not a fan of Hornung as a kicker. Even for his era he usually wasn't an accurate kicker with only, really one good season.

Analysis: Joel Bussert MMQB All-Time Draft Team

By John Turney

After looking at my own team and it's oddities I will take a look at the other 11 teams on the MMQB All-Time Draft Team project.

Bussert's team:
Joel picked two right defensive ends, neither really projects as a strong-side end but both were very good, Smith being, in our view, on of the top five All-Time. Randy White and Warren Sapp are both up-the-field rush tackles, neither a "shade" or nose type so if Bussert wanted to play odd-man fronts White and Sapp would have to play over a center and that was not their forte. 

Lawrence Taylor was taken #1 overall but was put into a 4-3 defense. Perhaps that is not the best use of his skills. Hanburger was a right linebacker but here he'd have to project to cover a tight end something that he would not have done as much as the left linebackers of his day. 

Jack Butler was a fine corner but his true greatness was as a right safety rather than defensive halfback. The safeties are ideal with Houston a strong safety and Wood a fine free or right safety. 
 Forrest Gregg would have to be moved to left tackle, but he's someone who could project there and do well. He was a top-notch pass protector who had "left tackle feet" if you will. Bussert would be able to run all backfield formations with a true fullback in Csonka.
These are all great choices, all well above the league averages at their positions during their career. 

Saturday, July 15, 2017

1972 Rams Uniform Contest

LOOKING BACK
By John Turney

In 1972 Carrol Rosenbloom acquired the Los Angeles Rams via a trade with Robert Irsay. Irsay received cash and the Baltimore Colts, the team Rosenbloom had owned since the early 1950s.

That season he held a contest for Rams fans to design the new Rams uniforms which were to be introduced in 1973.

Here are the ads that appeared in Pro! magazine, the Official program of the NFL and also in newspapers.


How much the entries to the contest were used is not known but here is the final product, though not the final iteration. In preseason the white trim on the blue jerseys and the gold trim on the white jerseys were removed.





The winner of the contest was Victor Marcelli of Van Nuys, California. 


In 2019 the Rams will don new uniforms and it is our understanding the Rams will be seeking some fan input into the process. Again, how much of it is used remains to be seen.

Until then the Rams are wearing a hodgepodge of uniform elements. New pants and white horns and white facemasks to go with the St. Louis-era jerseys. The Rams did hold a poll to decide if the Rams facemasks were to be white or blue to go with the new white Rams horns. The fans chose white.

So with a uniform put together pell-mell for the next two seasons, Rams fans can at least hope for something good in 2019. If they keep the Nike influence out, as much as possible that is, perhaps there will be a chance for a well-designed uniform.

Until then, print out the contest page from 1972 and send in your ideas.