Friday, April 8, 2016

"Mudhead" Photo by Robert Riger

The Works of Robert Riger
(Part 3 of 3)
By Chris Willis, NFL Films

"Mudhead" is Packers tackle Forrest Gregg
Credit: Robert Riger
The last post of this week on the works of Robert Riger focuses on perhaps his most famous photo. The Mudhead shot has probably been seen by more football fans, and non-football fans, than any other football image ever taken. One of the biggest question asked when glancing at the photo- who’s the player caked in mud?
It’s none other than Packers Hall of Fame tackle Forrest Gregg.

Gregg played 13 seasons with the Packers mostly under Vince Lombardi. The great coach always called Gregg “the finest player I ever coached.” He played in 188 consecutive games, made 9 Pro Bowls, won 6 NFL Championships (including three Super Bowls) and was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1977.

He was also in the right place, at the right time for Robert Riger.
Robert Riger
On December 10, 1960 Robert Riger was in San Francisco covering the Packers game against the 49ers. Stepping onto the sidelines at Kezar Stadium his shoes quickly became filthy in a quagmire of mud, as the city of San Francisco saw a weekend of rain in early December. Shooting photos in these conditions would be a challenge. But the artist from New York was up to it.

The 1960 Packers weren’t quite the team of the 1960’s yet. At this point Vince Lombardi had just turned the team from being the worse franchise in the NFL to a tie for first place in the Western Division. A win against the 49ers and Rams the following week would give them the title.

But the game against the 49ers would turn out to be a muddy affair. Both teams slopping through the deep mud, going nowhere. In the second quarter the Packers Paul Hornung kicks a 38-yard field goal to give Green Bay a 3-0 halftime lead.
In the second half both teams did more of the same- going nowhere in the mud. It wasn’t until the 4th quarter that the Packers finally put away the pesky 49ers. Hornung did all the damage by scoring on a 28-yard touchdown run- diving head first into the end zone and sliding for five yards- and kicking a 23-yard field goal to give the Packers a 13-0 victory.

Late in the game Riger settled on the Packers sidelines. As players were getting muddier and muddier Riger started focusing on the players on the bench, rather than the action on the field. The 49ers were trying to mount a drive behind Y.A. Tittle, who had just replaced an ineffective John Brodie. Tittle then throws an interception to Jesse Whittenton and at this moment Forrest Gregg leaps from the bench and roars with approval.
1960 Packers at 49ers "Mud" game. Packers bench, Dan Currie, Ray Nitschke,
and Willie Davis
Credit: Robert Riger
In the split second that Gregg stands up and yells, Robert Riger snaps a photo. Gregg then disappears to finish the game. Thinking nothing of it Riger walked off the muddy field as the final seconds ticked off. After the game Riger sat with Vince Lombardi on the team bus. The two discussed football strategy. The 49ers tried to run some shotgun formations and Lombardi was not impressed.

"Their shot gun offense backfired!” roared Lombardi with a laugh. Suddenly Vince became serious. "You know I think all that new formation business with the spread is a lot of junk. You play this game with your power. You do what you do best- and you do it again and again.” Typical Lombardi, even in just his second season as Packers head coach.

Riger and Lombardi chatted for nearly forty minutes on the bus talking about the performances of Paul Hornung and Jim Taylor. “(Jim) Taylor has great balance and he can cut quickly and our best play is a simple fullback slant. He can run it over tackle and if that holes closes he can come over the center or he can swing wide outside.” The coach even drew a few diagrams on Riger’s airline ticket. It was an intimate moment between coach and artist.

What Riger did not know was that a photo that would make him famous was sitting in his film case next to him. The photo became an instant classic. It won the grand prize award in Look Magazine’s Sports Photo contest beating out over 700 entries from the nation’s top photographers. The following year it appeared on the cover of the 1961 Green Bay Packers Yearbook.
1961 Packers Yearbook
As for the Packers they would go on to beat the Rams the following week and clinch the Western Division title. But two weeks after the “Mudhead” photo was taken they would eventually lose in the NFL Championship Game to the Philadelphia Eagles.

Over the next fifty years the photo continued to pop up in publications and now on the internet. Even Forrest Gregg used Riger’s image on the cover of his autobiography in 2009. Titled “Winning in the Trenches: A Lifetime of Football,” Gregg and author Andrew O’Toole choose the defining image of Gregg for the book.

 Robert Riger took thousands and thousands of football photos in his career. But none has defined what his work is truly about like the “Mudhead” photo.


  1. thanks for the background, and the in-depth interesting story Chris....sure enjoyed it. The Packers and 49ers played some interesting games during Lombardi's first three years with Green Bay.

    1. That is not Dan Currie in the photo. It is Jesse Whittenton or Hank Gremminger.

  2. My husband, Bill Butler, who played for the Packers in 1959 - his rookie year - says the photo of Forrest Gregg is the best football photo ever taken...

  3. It is my father Hank Gremminger #46 pictured to the left of Ray Nitschke.