For decades it's been reported that Elroy "Crazy Legs" Hirsch was the NFL's first true 'flanker'. In a recent post we showed that was not accurate. He played some flanker when the right end was on his side, when the tight end was on the opposite side it was Tom Fears who was the flanker.
Another inaccuracy is the old yarn that Sam Huff was the NFL's first true linebacker. Or Joe Schmidt or Bill George. Wrong on all counts. The first true MLBer was someone else.
Coach TJ Troup wrote, "The Washington Redskins were the first team to use the standard 4-3 defense on virtually every down for a complete season making Chuck Drazenovich the first true middle linebackers".
Troup is someone who has the gravitas to make such a statement. He is the author of The Birth of Football's Modern 4-3 Defense: The Seven Seasons That Changed the NFL
Back to Drazenovich. The 4-3 defense had been around for a while. One can see teams use it in the 1940s but none did it full time. They might employ it for a specific game or series. We've seen the Brookly Tigers use it some as well as other teams.
It began to creep into NFL defenses in the early 1950s and was becoming more common. But 1954 was a watershed moment. Both New York and Washington opened the season using it, thus making Drazenovich one of the first two "regular MLBers" along with John Cannady but the Giants didn't stick with it for the whole season, reverting back to the 5-2 they had used in previous years. So, at best, Cannady gets partial credit.
As for Huff, Troup's film study showed he began his career as a defensive tackle before moving to linebacker in his rookie season of 1956. The Lions and Schmidt and Bears with George (and others) migrated to the 4-3 in the mid-1950s, but it was Washington and Drazenovich who got there first and used the 4-3 for an entire season, from start to finish.
Jonathan Rand's book on linebackers say that Bill George was the first middle linebacker in 1954. And and Doug Farar's book says the first true middle linebacker was Samm Huff when he got drafted in 1956.ReplyDelete
why do you think you know more than them?
Why not flip the question? Were did Rand and Farrar get their information?Delete
Troup watches full game films, and does it for all the teams, as much as is available to him.
As good a writers as Rand and Farrar are, they don't watch the kind of film Troup does.
Also, Pro Football Journal has debunked lots of myths over the years. That Elroy Hirsch was not a flanker, that the 46 defense didn't begin with the '85 Bears, that the 1964 Colts used zone blitzes and all of it comes from watching the films.
So, we stand by the story, and it's not a close call
I don't know what level of research Rand or Farar implemented, but Coach Troup looked at game film....I'm relatively new (12-15 months) to this blog, but have read ALL the history posts dating back to its beginning in 2011 and if TJ Troup asserts something about(especially pre-AFL) the history of the game, I'm believing that unless/until someone specifically refutes him.....ReplyDelete
That is all.
I saw Clayton Tonnemaker playing MLB for the Packers in 1950.ReplyDelete
Have seen the Brooklyn Tigers in a 4-3 in the 1940s, don't know who the MLB was---it was a nice color film. But they didn't use it all game. Teams played the 4-3 and thus had a MLB but they key is if they did it every game in any season.Delete